ie8 fix

ThinkPad Tablet: Ready for the boardroom (review)

By | September 23, 2011, 6:34am PDT

Summary: The ThinkPad Tablet by Lenovo is a Honeycomb slate that has typical ThinkPad engineering and quality of construction. It is as comfortable in the boardroom as it is the living room.

Android tablets are a dime a dozen, but the folks behind the ThinkPad line of notebooks are looking to change that. The ThinkPad Tablet by Lenovo brings professional styling, sturdy construction and special features to the tablet that are unique to the genre. Android is ready for the boardroom.

The ThinkPad Tablet has typical black styling familiar of the line of laptops, and while a bit heavier than some Android tablets there is no mistaking the solid construction. The attention to detail is evident in every aspect of the tablet, from the solid casing to the buttons beneath the screen covered with Corning Gorilla Glass. The ThinkPad Tablet will satisfy anyone wanting to give a professional image.

Check out the ThinkPad Tablet with pen and Keyboard Folio captured in photos


Image Gallery: ThinkPad Tablet with optional pen input and Keyboard Folio Image Gallery: Charge Image Gallery: Charge

Hardware

Specs as reviewed:

  • OS: Android 3.1 Honeycomb
  • CPU: NVIDIA Tegra 2 dual core mobile processor (1.0GHz)
  • Display: 10.1” Multi-Touch Capacitive-Touch IPS Display, 1280 x 800 resolution, 16:10 aspect ratio
  • Memory: 1GB system RAM, 32GB storage (expandable through SD slot)
  • Cameras: 5MP rear-facing; 2MP front-facing camera
  • Connectivity: 802.11b/g/n, Bluetooth 2.1+EDR, SIM slot for 3G (not tested)
  • Ports: Full USB 2.0, MicroUSB 2.0, MiniHDMI, 3.5mm combo jack, DC-in jack for AC adapter, dock port
  • Battery: 3250 mAh Li-polymer
  • Measurements: 10.3 x 7.2 x 0.56 inches
  • Weight: 1.6 pounds

The specs of the ThinkPad are fairly typical of the genre, but Lenovo has included some special stuff to make this stand out from the crowd. Foremost is the use of an N-Trig dual digitizer which allows optional pen input on the screen in addition to the typical multi-touch input. The pen rests in a silo on the tablet when not in use.

Lenovo put a full SD slot on the ThinkPad, and a regular USB port that works with the optional portfolio case. The USB port can be used with standard USB flash drives for file exchange. File transfer can be done via the SD slot, too.

The 10.1-inch IPS screen is not the brightest I have tested, but it has outstanding viewing angles which is a good trait for a tablet. The front-facing camera does a decent job with video chatting, and the speaker, while not anything special, is quite loud for a tablet.

In a move rare for a Honeycomb tablet, the ThinkPad Tablet has four hardware buttons beneath the screen (in portrait orientation). These are a Lock Screen Rotation, Browser launcher, Back, and a Home button. These buttons are very rigid and can be hard to press. I find I end up using soft buttons on the screen out of habit.

There are two cameras on the ThinkPad, a 2MP front-facing camera and a 5MP camera on the back. The front camera delivered decent video chatting using Google Talk. The rear camera is nothing spectacular, as I found photos taken with it to be very basic. This tablet will not replace your basic point-and-shoot given its lackluster quality photos, not to mention its unwieldy size for snapping shots.

The ThinkPad construction used in the tablet make it easily the most rugged tablet I have used. It is heavy at 1.6 pounds, but it feels nice and solid in the hand.

Software

Lenovo is aiming the ThinkPad Tablet at the enterprise worker, and the software that comes standard reflects that aim. While there is plenty of entertainment software (Slacker, Netflix, Kindle, Zinio, Angry Birds), the tablet is loaded with apps for the worker. These include LANDesk, Computrace, Citrix Receiver, and McAfee Mobile Security. A full version of Documents to Go comes standard allowing viewing/editing of MS Office documents.

Lenovo has customized Honeycomb 3.1 to add a home screen launcher and a favorite apps wheel for easy access to the apps used most often. The Lenovo App Shop is front and center offering apps the company deems fitting for the ThinkPad.

The onscreen keyboard included on the tablet is the flexT9 keyboard by Nuance. This keyboard has good predictive text and autocorrection that starts learning from your typing as soo as you begin using it. I found it to be a decent keyboard, and it works with the optional pen to allow coarse editing of documents by pen. This experience was variable, and perhaps it would be better over time.

The web browser is typical Android with some special features. In the Settings screen there is a Labs function that makes web pages display in a full screen mode. Swiping in from either the left or right side of the screen causes a wheel menu to appear with common browser functions, such as Next and Previous. I normally use the Dolphin Browser on Android tablets, but this is a decent alternative.

The optional pen works with the MyScript Notes Mobile app that is preinstalled and uses a notebook metaphor to allow taking ink notes with the pen. Handwriting can be automatically converted to digital text if desired, or ink notes can be left as written. The latter worked better for me, as the ink-to-text conversion was not very accurate. The pen is the only input method allowed with the Notes app, which was a bit odd given the presence of an Android keyboard.

Performance, Keyboard folio, and conclusion »

Topics

James Kendrick has been using mobile devices since they weighed 30 pounds, and has been sharing his insights on mobile technology for almost that long.

Disclosure

James Kendrick

James Kendrick has no affiliations or relationships that need to be disclosed.

Biography

James Kendrick

James Kendrick has been using mobile devices since they weighed 30 pounds, and has been sharing his insights on mobile technology for almost that long. Prior to joining ZDNet, James was the Founding Editor of jkOnTheRun, a CNET Top 100 Tech Blog that was acquired by GigaOM in 2008 and is now part of that prestigious tech network. James' writing has appeared in many print publications: Smartphone and Pocket PC Magazine, Information Week and Laptop Magazine to name a few. James' coverage of the mobile technology sector has regularly appeared in the New York Times, Salon.com and CNN/ Fortune online. Not just a writer, James has filmed numerous video reviews and how-tos that have garnered well over a million viewers. He has appeared on local news segments and been interviewed by the Associated Press on mobile technology topics. Additionally, James has been podcasting about mobile technology for years.

36
Comments

Join the conversation!

Just In

Will pen and paper still look more professional?
ingle Updated - 3rd Oct
My ThinkPad T61p is over 4 years old, but people still ask me if it is new. I keep it clean, but the timelessness of the design is what makes it what it is.
(Unfortunately I can only play Deus Ex at the low resolution of 1650x1050 - not much you can do about older hardware...)
Personally I find it easier to flip pages and scribble with a real pen on real paper then sort out the notes that I do not need from a meeting rather than keep everything in a digital form. Maybe a tablet which would just be used to record audio( like any phone or MP3 player from 2004) and then do a transcription would also be a good idea. Mind you transcribing takes 5 times more time than taking notes.
Would I have the money, and a need for a tablet, the ThinkPad Tablet with the digitizer pen would be the way to go for me.
0.2? 0.4? ThinkPad is not consumer and android isn't enterprise. FAIL. If you want some ROI build Win8 tablet prototypes and spend your effort refining your hardware down to the last detail so when Win8 ships you're ready with a super kickass product. Dinking around in the android swamp is so worthless you'll not only lose money you won't even learn anything valuable from it that will help you with future products .
0 Votes
+ -
RE: ThinkPad Tablet: Ready for the boardroom (review)
Return_of_the_jedi Updated - 23rd Sep
@Johnny Vegas

If we could see your face, it's probably red with android envy.
@Johnny Vegas R U F* Kiddin? Windows 8 on a tablet? Can you say viri infected bloated worthless POS all in one breath? I can!
@SpankyFrost Are you seriously implying that Windows 8 will be bad on tablets??? The interface is perfect for tablets. I agree however that it is completely impractical on laptops,...
And are you really still stuck on the whole virus thing. I can't remember the last time I got a virus, because it was probably before I even got XP. Just download a free Antivirus and you'll be fine. Android is not suited for anything. It is laggy, impractical and actually pretty useless. I fully agree with Johnny Vegas. I absolutely love Thinkpads, and I have no doubt that this has an absolutely perfect build quality but Android is not suited for business users, or any user who doesn't like using a laggy OS for that matter. The only reason why Android still has any Marketshare is because a lot of people don't want to buy the iPhone or the iPad by conviction and don't yet know about Windows Phone. As soon as people know what they're missing out on, they'll be flocking over to Apple and/or Microsoft.
This sounds like a device that they designed to run Windows 8 and are just selling with Android until Win8 appears. A lot of folks like the idea of a stylus on a tablet, so they may do well with it. The big details I wanted to hear were the price and the actual number of hours for battery life. All day for one person is half a day for another.
0 Votes
+ -
@BillDem Lenovo's forthcoming IdeaPad P1 is a better fit for Windows users, like me. happy

update: in fact, lenovo's site just made room to display another device (like the P1?) at www.lenovo.com/products/us/tablet/
0 Votes
+ -
Price and Battery
GSG 23rd Sep
@BillDem I have one and on the Battery life, with some tweaking of settings, I can get 10-12 hours. Of course if my wireless is on when I'm not actively using the internet, or I'm using an app (like Angry Birds) that uses a lot of Battery, it will be less.

Now on to cost. First, don't order direct from Lenovo as they are more expensive. I got the 32GB with the Pen from PC Connection for $549. I originally tried to order direct from Lenovo and also ordered the keyboard folio, but as the folio was on backorder and they wouldn't ship without it, I cancelled my order and placed a new one without the folio at PC Connection.

I don't have a smart phone, and I've never used a tablet before, so there was a short learning curve on the "swipe" and on Android itself. I set up the Citrix receiver and have been able to use some of my work applications. The one I use the most works on there only if I want to check statuses, stop and start the processes, etc... so it's good for after hours and travelling.

Overall, I'm pleased with it, and feel that it was worth it.
0 Votes
+ -
Marketing?
p.vinnie@... 23rd Sep
The product they created is surely going to grab attention of professional folks; but they have to work hard to get their word out there. Android is becoming fastest adopted operating system for enterprise because they have greater ability to customise many aspects of it.

Thinkpad is number one in enterprise but they need to learn from Apple how to market something.

First of all they did not give separate name for their product, which makes it difficult to search and pin down the product in search engines. Thinkpad is broad range, Lenovo had windows based tablets before and they have now two Android tablets (ideapad and thinkpad); so all combinations provide more broad results making it difficult to search for a product. Samsung uses Galaxy tab, motorola came up with Xoom, similarly "lennovo thinkpad BoardPad" could be distinct name for the product.

Product reviews were very slow to come. Its been at-least 1 month since they launched the product and you can see very few credible user reviews coming in the market.

Product is just coming in Europe and price in Europe is at-least $150 more than US. Every electronic gadget company is greedy when it comes to Europe, but Lenovo had better opportunity to crack the market by selling at same price as they sell in US.

Product is still slowly appearing in the market; very few places it is available. Also keyboard folio is not yet available in most places.
0 Votes
+ -
taxes are extra
AtlantaTerry 23rd Sep
@p.vinnie@... is the price difference between Europe and the US due to VAT (Value Added Tax) that must be added? Or is the price in Europe that is quoted prior to VAT?
@AtlantaTerry import/export/excise taxes may be in that price too. They most likely can't sell it for exactly the same as the US price simply because of various different taxes.
@AtlantaTerry
I know prices in US are displayed Ex tax and tax is added at checkout; whereas prices in UK are displayed Inc Tax and only shipping is added in the end.
So I asked a friend to provide his zipcode in NewYork and used that to calculate end user price. I then compare it for several items in the marketplace and found that most companies charge more in UK than they do in US.

I asked an expert about this and he said that companies sell products at the highest possible price (to maximize profit). As most companies can get away with selling at inflated price in Europe, they do that.
@p.vinnie@...

"Android is becoming fastest adopted operating system for enterprise because they have greater ability to customise many aspects of it."

I never saw so far any entrprise using android.I dont know where u got that idea, but so far on business ground there is only 2 OS who are really used Windows Xp/7 and Linux RedHat/Suse

Android is far from beeing a business OS.Android is just good for basic task like consuming content.
Never read a tablet test where there is no mention of the iWord as a comparison. Guess this must be either vastly superior, or you don't do Apple?
0 Votes
+ -
Contributr
@barneyhaye I didn't compare it to any other tablet, iPad or Android. This review stands on its own.
0 Votes
+ -
I've had this tablet for a week now. I've had an iPad for a year. The Thinkpad Tablet (yes, bad marketing in the name) is nowhere as slick as the iPad. But I bought it for the stylus. Unfortunately, the MyScript product is buggy. Other note-takers handle digital ink better (handwriting recognition: bah), but have no good options for export to Evernote, etc.

What's really needed in an Android version of OneNote with good ink handling.
Looks great, too bad I just bought an Asus Eee Slider tablet. I love the fact that it has a built-in physical keyboard, makes writing so much faster.
Had a chance to play with it for a short while - heavy as a brick. Solid, but you really feel the weight
0 Votes
+ -
Finally!
camcost@... 23rd Sep
After a whole multitude of lousy Android tablets released over close to a two-year period, it's great to see that finally some decent droid tablets are sneaking onto the salesfloor.

Now, it's just a matter of time to win-back those of us who were burned and disappointed by the less-than-stellar early offerings. Apple avoided this pitfall by offering a top-notch product on it's first initial launch. Though Android came first (in tablet form) it's been playing a catch-up game and finally has some players that can actually hit when at bat!

Finally!
@camcost@... I didn't think the Xoom and Samsung (amongst others) were "lousy" tablets.
I have been testing and evaluating the Thinkpad Tablet for my work, and I have found that the stuttering and stalling mentioned in the article quite a nuisance. Also, the interface built into this is Android implementation is so not intuitive and so poorly documented, that I really can't recommend this for general consumption. Citrix Receiver will have to be upgraded out of the box. Cisco AnyConnect can only work if it is rooted. The touch interface needs to be finessed to work, but it only responds if you use much force. This causes intermittent missed button pushes and sometimes it will cause menus to show up because of overcompensation of pushing harder than necessary. I found that after playing the Angry Birds that comes with it to help with knowing how to use the interface and getting a feel for it, but having to learn this when using a Toshiba touch screen monitor or ipad just works makes this frustrating. The wireless and VPN interface is about as intuitive as using Linux conf files setting circa 1995. Once an app is in use, the app works. But the OS and touchscreen are really not user friendly.
Where is the MS Office and exchange integrations. Useless without it for most business. Power Point and Exchange are used on the road all the time. It is why I use a laptop on the road.
0 Votes
+ -
Contributr
@hayneiii@... As stated in the article, Office docs can be viewed and edited using Docs 2 Go. Not a perfect solution but works pretty well.
@hayneiii@... Exchange integration has been in android since what, 2.1 or 2.2? It's in Honeycomb also. And Docs to Go works pretty good for MS Documents.
0 Votes
+ -
ThinkPadTabletForums.com
alan27inla 23rd Sep
There's a great community that's sprung up on http://ThinkPadTabletForums.com all about the ThinkPad Tablet. Definitely recommend it.
0 Votes
+ -
virus
bannedfromzdnetagainandagain 23rd Sep
and it even has McAfee Mobile Security anti virus software! being infected with malware and having the need for an antivirus software must be some kind of requirement for the wintel crowd to count as enterprise ready. and the stylus! insert famous steve jobs quote here...

ok, ok, you don't have to look it up:
"If you see a stylus they blew it".
@bannedfromzdnetagainandagain "If you see a stylus they blew it"

Why is that? Ohhhh, because Papa Steve said so. Got it.
0 Votes
+ -
Don't get it
oneleft Updated - 23rd Sep
How does an optional pen and folio keyboard make it the most versatile tablet you've used? An optional pen and folio keyboard is, well, optional for every tablet. That all 3 are branded by the same company shouldn't make them all special when they perform like every other optional pen and folio tablet.

What am I missing?
0 Votes
+ -
Batteries...
kcredden2 23rd Sep
I forgot to ask. How are the batteries? Are they removeable/replaceable? Or have to send it back to Lenevo? That's a deal breaker if they're not user replaceable.

- Kc
0 Votes
+ -
FAIL.
MSFTWorshipper 23rd Sep
Microsoft just sucked all the oxygen out of the Android tablet market by announcing Windows 8. Now everyone who wasn't planning on buying the iPad will wait for Windows 8 tablets!
@MSFTWorshipper
True!
But Win 8 is just old wine in new bottle; at-least based on what I found about it so far. I hope they can get rid of legacy support mentality and develop something from scratch.

They also blew up when they created office 365. They had good opportunity to prove themselves in that sector; but they created something which is companion or add-on to desktop office implementation instead of becoming office on the web. It's not as if they don't have brilliant engineers who can deliver; it is management strategy which restricts what they can do. Certainly in case of Office 365 they just invented product to stop enterprises going to Google Apps. And they did not develop it complete office replacement because they did not want to let go license revenue.
@MSFTWorshipper There is still plenty of oxygen out there for Android and plenty of time before Win 8 hits in which they can grab market share. Of there is no given that Win 8 will be a success in tablets so it might not even end up being a factor at all.
0 Votes
+ -
Until they make the battery owner-replaceable (at a decent cost of course), I for one will not be buying one. 10-12 hours per charge x ~500 charges, means the average life span of such a tablet will be less than 2 years! Get real, manufacturers!
Since when did an AntiVirus product become a business product?! Amazing.
I would like to own one of these, but would prefer to wait for Win8. Currently, I use an android tab - the Acer A500 - which is OK but I think working with Win across my devices would be easier.

I like the Think pad brand and currently own two Thinkpads. If the build quality is equal to my experience based on my laptops, I think it would be a great device. I also hope that like their laptops, these or newer models of the Think pad tabs should allow for a certain level of user-replaceable options.

Maybe next year...?
0 Votes
+ -
I agree.
WilErz 25th Sep
@ crystalsoldier

The hardware looks good, but the OS isn't compelling. If the battery life is sufficient for a full day of active use, I'll probably buy one once a Windows 8 version ships.

For Lenovo, it's a good idea to get some early hardware feedback from an Android version, to see how well it competes with Apple, etc. That way, when they ship the real Windows 8 product next year, they'll have a better chance of making a good first impression.
0 Votes
+ -
My ThinkPad T61p is over 4 years old, but people still ask me if it is new. I keep it clean, but the timelessness of the design is what makes it what it is.
(Unfortunately I can only play Deus Ex at the low resolution of 1650x1050 - not much you can do about older hardware...)
Personally I find it easier to flip pages and scribble with a real pen on real paper then sort out the notes that I do not need from a meeting rather than keep everything in a digital form. Maybe a tablet which would just be used to record audio( like any phone or MP3 player from 2004) and then do a transcription would also be a good idea. Mind you transcribing takes 5 times more time than taking notes.
Would I have the money, and a need for a tablet, the ThinkPad Tablet with the digitizer pen would be the way to go for me.

Join the conversation!

Formatting +
BB Codes - Note: HTML is not supported in forums
  • [b] Bold [/b]
  • [i] Italic [/i]
  • [u] Underline [/u]
  • [s] Strikethrough [/s]
  • [q] "Quote" [/q]
  • [ol][*] 1. Ordered List [/ol]
  • [ul][*] · Unordered List [/ul]
  • [pre] Preformat [/pre]
  • [quote] "Blockquote" [/quote]
ie8 fix

The best of ZDNet, delivered

ZDNet Newsletters

Get the best of ZDNet delivered straight to your inbox

Facebook Activity

White Papers, Webcasts, & Resources
ie8 fix