Verizon Wireless: Taking account security too far

Verizon Wireless: Taking account security too far

Summary: Customer security is important, but my recent experience with Verizon Wireless shows that when the effort interferes with the ability to use the service properly, it has been taken too far.

SHARE:
TOPICS: Security, Verizon
20

I am a security-conscious guy, I do what I can to protect my information online and I appreciate the efforts of companies I deal with that do the same. But my recent experience with Verizon Wireless shows that when the security effort interferes with the customer's ability to use the service properly, it has been taken too far.

A couple of weeks ago I bought a Samsung 4G LTE Mobile Hotspot from Verizon and signed up for the monthly data plan. Since the transaction, enough time has passed for me to review the device on ZDNet, take it back when it started failing and replace it with a new one, and chronicle that experience. During the time that passed since starting the service I've already received the first monthly bill via snail mail from Verizon. What I can't do is go online and track my data usage due to the insane security process the carrier uses for online account activation.

The instructions that accompanied the Samsung device and data service made it clear that the only way to track data usage is through a My Verizon account online. This data tracking is important as my monthly plan ($50) gets me 5GB of data usage, after which a hefty $10/GB overage fee kicks in. It is only prudent for me to keep a watchful eye on my data consumption through the My Verizon account. The problem is I can't do that.

Following the instructions laid out by Verizon on the day my service was activated, I went online to set up and activate the My Verizon account. It stepped me through a process of entering my personal information, including the all-important email address that Verizon will use to warn me when I start getting close to hitting my monthly data cap, and then it asked me for the phone number associated with my mobile hotspot service. I entered the number and was greeted with a screen that informed me Verizon would send a text message to the "phone" I was registering that included a temporary password to get the My Verizon account up and running.

The problem is the Samsung device is not a phone, and is not capable of receiving text messages, much less displaying them. The account activation process gave me a link to click for information about the process if that was the case, which told me that for security reasons the temporary password would be snail mailed to me. This would happen after spending 24 hours attempting to send a text message to the device. There was no other way forward, I would have to wait for the postman to bring me a letter from Verizon containing the temporary account password to finish create my online account. So not only can I not go online to pay my bill, I can't track my data usage which is what I really want to do. Little did I know it was only going to get worse.

It's in the mail, NOT »

Two weeks later I finally received a letter from Verizon that I was confident contained my password. I ripped it open, only to discover to my horror that not only was there no password indicated, it was my first monthly bill from the carrier. I only signed up two weeks ago, but I already received the first bill. It seems my monthly billing cycle ended the day after I signed up, so it was time to send me a bill. I could live with that, but there was still no password in the letter to go online. There was an instruction in the bill telling me to activate the My Verizon account as I had failed to do so yet.

I went online as instructed and repeated the personal information I had entered two weeks ago, only to hit the same screen asking for the device telephone number. I duly entered it in and was informed once again that the password would be send via text message, and if that failed for 24 hours they would mail me the temporary password. I was back to square one, and not happy about that.

I decided to call Verizon directly to get this account going, so I dialed the customer service number provided in the monthly bill. I spent 5 minutes going through the menu loop, and then finally a live person answered the call. After going through an account of what I was trying to do, the rep (who was very cordial) informed me that she was sorry but there was no way to bypass the mailing of the password. She also warned me that no matter what I did, I should not go back online and enter the device phone number again as that would start the whole password generation process all over again.

I explained that I had just done that, and her response was that since it takes Verizon 2-3 weeks to generate and mail the first password to me, I had just started the process all over again. Basically when the password finally appears in my mailbox, it was going to be useless as the second attempt to register online had reset the temporary password and started the whole process all over again. What she was telling me was that I was now going to likely receive a second monthly bill before I was going to receive the letter with the password inside.

I admit it was a big effort to keep from losing my temper with her, as I realized she wasn't responsible for the insane process designed to protect the security of an account that had not even been opened yet. She admitted this procedure annoys many new account holders who call in. Then she informed me there was a way to get past the snail mail requirement after all, if I was willing to go through a "little bit of an effort." I was in no way prepared for what she was about to tell me to do.

Take someone else's phone and you're all set! »

Since the problem of getting my account activated was due to the inability to receive a text message on the mobile hotspot device, all I needed to do according to the customer service rep was to enlist the aid of a friend or family member with a Verizon phone. Once I had a surrogate phone lined up, I simply needed to call Verizon customer support again and have my confederate's phone transferred to my new data account. This would let Verizon send a text message to my "new" phone, and get my online account activated.

Once that had been successfully verified, all I would have to do is call Verizon back and have the phone transferred back to the original account holder. Sure it would take about half an hour, and she couldn't verify if there would be any transfer fees or not, but it would sure get me what I wanted.

I admit that I was near speechless at this point in the conversation with Verizon. That they would recommend moving existing phones around, creating lots more work for both the customer and the carrier, just blew me away. It would have been far easier for Verizon to simply let its representative set up my online account over the phone. By the time I was talking to a real person on this call, I had verified my phone number, account number, address and social security number. That's not good enough; Verizon is concerned about my account security, and since I refused to dupe the carrier into sending me a password as suggested, I am now waiting another few weeks for a letter with my password inside. That's assuming Verizon really sends it as they say they will, but I haven't seen one yet, even the one the carrier tells me won't be any good when it arrives. This is security taken too far, and as I can't track data usage I'm postponing any trips to Canada with the $2,100/GB roaming charge.

Image credit: Flickr user extended.epiphany

Topics: Security, Verizon

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily email newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.

Talkback

20 comments
Log in or register to join the discussion
  • RE: Verizon Wireless: Taking account security too far

    Why are you so upset? This process was obviously set up by a security expert to protect your valuable account. After all, everyone knows how safe it is to send passwords thru the mail.

    Come on man, learn a little about how a real security expert designs systems!
    bump911
    • Reminds me of att

      This is the reason why Att should not be allowed to purchase Tmobile. As both Verizon and Att customer service are only getting worse. They are concerned about billing you, more than they are helping you or providing you a service you PAY for.

      and tmobile does. Please dont confuse it with service.
      Uralbas
  • RE: Verizon Wireless: Taking account security too far

    How about the US Postal Service security. They have an on-line form for registering a change of address. My in-laws just moved their second residence. However, USPS requires that you verify you are the responsible party for the address by allowing them to charge $1 to a credit card billed to one of the two addresses. Except that, because this is my in-laws second residence, they cannot complete the form successfully. Instead, they can go to the post office, fill out an index card form, and drop it off without having any identity verification.

    Yea, for on-line security!
    jglopic
  • Avoiding Godwin's Law

    I have it on good authority that Verizon's entire back-office operation, including its billing department, is outsourced to none other than Satan, who uses eternally condemned Evil People to handle all aspects of Verizon's billing and support.

    Your account could well be handled by Vlad the Impaler. I had to deal with former Emperor Caligula. These are the kinds of people that Verizon has creating and operating its billing operation.
    Robert Hahn
    • RE: Verizon Wireless: Taking account security too far

      @Robert Hahn This is patentedly inaccurate good sir, Verizon employees are not condemned souls - infact the Verzion initiation process strips them of their soul all together. (Seriously they're good people working for a jacked company - many of them "give up" along the way...)
      ITSamurai
  • Easier fix for checking data usage on that specific device.

    Once u have the mifi connected via wireless type in 192.168.1.1 in the web browser and it will take u to the router settings. Normally the default password is admin for other devices this samsung requires the password for the network (the one under the battery cover. Once imputed correctly u will see a tab that says data. Click that and there u have ur data usage from cycle to cycle.
    Adktoyota
    • RE: Verizon Wireless: Taking account security too far

      @Adktoyota That only shows usage per session. I want to track it for the whole billing cycle.
      JamesKendrick
      • I went through the same thing

        The best thing to do is go to your nearest Verizon store and have it set up there in person with the sales representatives. And if they're too incompetent (as some of them are) to help you out, ask for the store manager.<br><br>I'm not being flippant here. This actually happened.
        ScorpioBlue
  • Or install the &quot;my verizon&quot; software

    on your laptop and that software will use the phone number of the mifi and allow you to receive a text message on your computer.
    JT82
    • RE: Verizon Wireless: Taking account security too far

      @JT82 Neither of Verizon's 4G hotspot devices work with Verizon Access Manager software as you are indicating.
      JamesKendrick
  • RE: Verizon Wireless: Taking account security too far

    Swapping devices around will not incur a fee, but it is a damned difficult way to go about doing it.

    I find it difficult to believe that they don't have a way for a customer service rep to set up an online account for you over the phone.....I know that at&t does....

    My recommendation is actually to try calling in a second time and see if the next agent you talk to is more knowledgeable....this might have been a trainee who doesn't know about all the systems yet.

    One thing in particular that makes me think this is that she asked you to call in twice....actually the PROPER way to handle that kind of issue is to offer to call you back at your own convenience....call center representatives are graded on the basis of a number of factors, one of which is the '7 day repeats', you don't want customers calling back in about the same issue because it hurts your own stats, which can affect your pay. This is why an experienced rep will offer to call YOU back to prevent the repeat, rather than ask you to call in.

    It's worth trying again and seeing if you get a different answer.
    Doctor Demento
  • RE: Verizon Wireless: Taking account security too far

    I had the same problem with passwords to access the verizon account for a USB Broadband Modem I bought over two years ago. Never got the problem resolved after many attempts, very strange but true. Then canceled the service after two years for that and other reasons like overcharges and software update problems.
    EdBoutros
  • Had a similar problem on the website

    Verizon's security is really fouled up these days. I tried to log onto their website -- I'm a 20+ year customer -- and it wouldn't let me on without my "security question," whatever that is. Finally I backed into it through the Verizon landline website. What a mess!
    Kalnel
  • RE: Verizon Wireless: Taking account security too far

    q2qq
    CLINTFOX
  • RE: Verizon Wireless: Taking account security too far

    Never.
    james347
  • RE: Verizon Wireless: Taking account security too far

    As a long time Verizon customer, I can tell you that the company has gotten too big for all the parts to work together coherently. It goes far beyond security. The worker bees know their processes are hosed but management is oblivious or helpless. That is why I dumped them and went with a reseller, oh, and also because I was tired of their price gouging.
    M.M.Grimes
  • RE: Verizon Wireless: Taking account security too far

    You have 2 options here. The first is borrow a 4G handset slap the sim in and you can send the temp password to that phone. The other option is active an old 3G phone floating around an submit the request again for a temp password. Yeah I realize it's a lot of work for such a simple little thing.
    Speedracerkb1978
  • RE: Verizon Wireless: Taking account security too far

    This is outrageous! Cliches such as "between a rock and a hard place" and "up a creek without a paddle" only hint at how this situation is unbelievable.
    charleyj98
  • RE: Verizon Wireless: Taking account security too far

    I use a 4G dongle, with the same 5G/$50 month plan and it works fine with VZ access manager once U learn how to set it up. I have never had trouble going into VZN's web site and seeing usage for either my phone or the 4G dongle; go to the store and they will help U out.
    Pete Walls
    keynthwest@...
  • RE: Verizon Wireless: Taking account security too far

    The reason it is set up that way has NOTHING to do with security at all. You give them a lot more credit than is deserved. The reason is they were too cheap to develop a separate task scenario re the UI experience design for HotSpot device users. They thought they could use existing their existing UI for phone users for their new HotSpot users and avoid paying the costs of development for such. This is what we call in usability engineering false economy and it eventually (sometimes quickly.. sometimes slowly) destroys an entire companies. When you leave design like this to executives and their opinions, this is the kind of poor design you get... and is the reason why Apple is continually leads the pack re usability because Apple places more than 1/2 of its treasure into usability. Yes, I know this for a fact.
    Anonyms