EU court upholds record €152m Telefonica antitrust fine

EU court upholds record €152m Telefonica antitrust fine

Summary: The huge fine, handed down for abusing its dominant broadband position, will have to be paid in full by Telefonica after its latest appeal failed.

TOPICS: Broadband, Telcos, EU

The European Court of Justice has upheld a €152m fine handed out to Spanish telecoms giant Telefonica for abusing its dominant position in the Spanish broadband market.

The fine — which was a record for a European telecoms firm at the time — relates to a period from 2001 to 2006, and was first handed out way back in 2007 by the EU General Court. Telefonica subsequently appealed the original decision, but the European Court of Justice has dismissed its claims and demanded that the fine be paid in full.

The original decision claimed that Telefonica had "abused their dominant position by imposing unfair prices on their competitors", essentially forcing other broadband providers to reduce their prices in order to compete with it. "The Commission considered that there was clear-cut abuse on the part of an undertaking holding a virtual monopoly and that the abuse was to be classified as 'very serious'," the judgement said.

This latest round of appeals has resulted in the EU Court of Justice upholding that original decision and dismissing Telefonica's appeal in its entirety. "The fine of €151,875,000 imposed by the Commission and upheld by the General Court therefore remains unchanged," the court said in a statement.

"The Court points out that, according to the findings of the General Court, the Commission demonstrated that there were potential anticompetitive effects that may have excluded competitors who were at least as efficient as Telefónica, which is sufficient to establish that the practice of squeezing margins was abusive."

One of Telefonica's defences was that it could not "reasonably have foreseen the Commission's interpretation of EU law" but this was rejected by the court, which claimed the Spanish company could and should have had a full understanding of the law and the European Commission's interpretation of those laws.

The court also said Telefonica had failed to prove that the fine, and its starting amount of €90m, was unfair.

Telefonica also disputed that its actions constituted a 'very serious' breach of EU antitrust laws by claiming that the geographical market was too small.

"The classification of an infringement as 'serious' or 'very serious' does not depend only on the size of the relevant geographic market but also on other criteria characterising the infringement," the EU countered.

Telefonica declined to comment on the fine.

Read more on Telefonica

Topics: Broadband, Telcos, EU

Steve Evans

About Steve Evans

Steve is a freelance journalist based in Madrid, specialising in technology and how it impacts businesses. His previous roles include web editor at Computer Business Review (CBR) and before that staff writer at a magazine that wrote about and sold collectable items.

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily email newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.


Log in or register to join the discussion

    "The industry needs to form security and surveillance-orientated groups, and to have a strong position on this. Things are happening at such a pace that they need to come together and have a clear position, making it clear to consumers what they feel, and how they feel about providing access to technology."
    As for the technological challenge itself of cost-efficiency given the new measures, Shaikh said there are still many more questions than answers.
    "We see a future where everything will be monitored, but how do we make sure we do the least amount of monitoring for the highest effect, and at the lowest cost?" he asked.
    "I've always said I appreciate the need for some surveillance, but we need maximum privacy, providing maximum anonymity and to try to provide as early detection as possible, minimising the need for surveillance."
    Firozal Mullar

    So Germans want the same privacy guarantees as American citizens? Surprise Germans you have them. We have no guarantees with Obama in the White House. He is spying on every call, email, and internet transaction of every American 24/7,and storing that information forever. The FISA Court, Congress....they only know what they are told. Look at what Obama has done with the IRS? Do you think he wasn't using the NSA to spy on his political opposition? That aside, Obama promised us better relationships around the world. So where do we have a better relationship? Not with Israel, not with England, not with Germany. Germany is one of our closest and most powerful allies, and Obama has left our relations in tatters. Nobody can remember when a close ally has ever publicly asked a high level official to be yanked from their country before. Merkel clearly did it to demonstrate her complete contempt for our weak, inept, INCOMPETENT, dishonest, divisive President. In a way its Karma. Europe, including the Germans, was gaga for Obama. Now they know. Folks everybody spies on everybody, but when you spy on friends you aren't supposed to get caught. Obama and his entire regime are so completely incompetent they can't even manage that.
    Firozal Mullar