Mint 15: Today's best Linux desktop (Review)

Mint 15: Today's best Linux desktop (Review)

Summary: Mint isn't just an outstanding Linux desktop, it's the best new desktop operating system of any kind available now.

TOPICS: Linux, PCs

As the years roll-by, every new update of Linux Mint impresses me more. Other desktop operating systems, such as Microsoft's Windows 8 may abandon the tried-and-true windows, icons, menus, and pointer (WIMP) desktop metaphor.  Others, such as Ubuntu with Unity try to keep some of the WIMP interface while expanding it for tablets and smartphones, but the Ubuntu-based Mint, with Cinnamon and MATE, has stayed true to the WIMP interface. As far as I'm concerned the latest version, Linux Mint 15, Olivia, is now not merely the best Linux desktop, it's the best desktop operating system of all.

Do you want a good, old-fashioned, hard-working windows, icons, menus, and pointers desktop? Then what you really want is Linux Mint 15.

That's not to say that if you're a Windows 7 or Mac OS X Mountain Lion user you should start downloading Mint now. For desktop users Mint is better than Windows 8 and other new operating systems, such as Fedora 18 with GNOME 3.6, but it doesn't knock the socks off older WIMP-based desktops. It's just much better for experienced desktop users than the newer, user-hostile desktop interfaces as such as Windows 8's Metro.

The best new WIMP desktop today: Linux Mint 15 (slideshow)

Why? The main reason is that Cinnamon, which is the Mint interface I chose to review rather than its close GNOME 2.x-based relative MATE, is designed for power-users who already know how to use a WIMP-style desktop. A Windows XP or 7 user who's never touched Linux in their life will find Mint Cinnamon far more user-friendly than Metro.

You don't have to take my word for it. You can download Linux Mint 15, which is now is a release candidate, and try it for yourself. Just keep in mind that thanks to Windows 8's Secure Boot system lock-in, it's very difficult to install any other operating system on a Windows 8 PC. The easily way of installing Mint, or anything else, on a Windows 8 is to use your PC's Unified Extensible Firmware Interface (UEFI) settings to turn Secure Boot off.

With the built-in Secure Boot bug out of the way, I think you'll find Mint to be an exceptional desktop. In my own case, I tested 64-bit Mint on two systems. The first is a Dell XPS 8300. This powerhouse desktop comes with a 3.4GHz quad-core Intel Core i7 processor. It also has 8GBs of RAM, a 2-Terabyte hard drive, and an AMD/ATI Radeon HD 5770 graphic card. My other test system is my tank of a laptop, a Lenovo ThinkPad T520 laptop. This computer boasts a 2.5GHz Intel Core i5 Processor, 4GBs of RAM, a 500GB hard drive and an integrated Intel HD Graphics 3000 processor.

On both systems, Mint ran flawlessly. This included automatic support for the ATI graphics, a Logitech QuickCam Pro 9000, and various Wi-Fi hardware. The days when Linux had trouble with commonplace PC hardware is history. In the event, you do have exotic hardware, however, Mint now includes a Driver Manager to make it easier to manage which driver to use with your devices.

Under the hood, hardcore Linux users will find the Linux 3.8 kernel. Mint stands on the shoulders of giants. It's built on top of Ubuntu 13.04, which, in turn, is based on Debian Linux.

Cinnamon itself is now up to version 1.8 and contains over a thousand new improvements and fixes since its last major version. The latest version of the Cinnamon file manager, Nemo, makes it simple to switch from multiple viewpoints including the oldie, but goodie, file-tree view. It also now comes with a feature that I've never been that much in love with: free-standing desktop applications. KDE users know them as Plasmoids, Android users know them as widgets, and I think they're a waste of desktop space whatever you call them. But, since every desktop operating system seem to have one version of them or another, I guess a lot of people must like them and now Mint Cinnamon has them under the name of Desklets.

Above this, Mint has the usual selection of end-user software. This includes LibreOffice 4.0.2 for the office suite: Thunderbird 17.0.5 for e-mail; Firefox 21.0 for Web browsing, Pidgin 2.10.7 for instant-messaging and so on. Say, you have your own favorite applications, as I do, Mint's Software Manager doubles as an app store and makes finding, downloading, and installing new programs easy. In my case, I switched in Evolution for Thunderbird and Chromium, Google's pure open-source version of Chrome, for the Web browser. Installing software in Linux now is as trivial as installing a new program on an iPhone.

You can also add Linux programs that aren't available through the Mint Software Manager. For these, simply download the DEB package version of the program, usually marked as being for Ubuntu and Debian, download it and then open the file. The package manager automatically starts and in a few seconds you'll have such programs as Google Chrome and the Steam game client. All of these programs, whether they came with the default set or added on, ran as smoothly as silk.

I only have one serious beef about the Mint's default software choices. They picked Totem, GNOME 3.x's media player, for video-playback. VLC, to my way of thinking, is simply the best media-player software on any platform. Fortunately, VLC is in the Software Manager so it's easy to install

The only really annoying thing about Mint is that you still can't do in-place updates from an older version to Mint 15. That's by design. Mint's developers feel that you'll avoid out of date software incompatibilities by forcing you to do a fresh install. True, but it also means you may need to back up and restore your home directories and files. I did this by restoring them up to an attached USB drive.

Finally, Mint has the same advantage that any Linux distribution has over its competitors: Its design is far more secure than Windows. There are such things as Linux viruses, but there have been only a handful of mostly harmless ones.. Practically speaking, Linux is the safest full desktop operating system you can run.

So, if you were to tell me today that you want a new desktop that works like your old XP Windows 7, or Ubuntu GNOME 2.x desktop, Mint 15 is what I would recommend. Yes, if you have Windows programs that won't on Linux, or Mac OS X, then you may need to stick with Windows, but for experienced computer users, Mint 15 is now the best desktop operating system out there.

How strongly do I feel that way? Those two test machines? They're also my main two production systems. I've already made the Mint 15 upgrade and I'm glad I did.

Related Stories:

Topics: Linux, PCs

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily email newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.


Log in or register to join the discussion
  • Why limit yourself?

    I have Windows 8 and Linux Mint dual-booting on my desktop machine. Best of both worlds.
    • +1... Even on my mbp

      It's all about choices right? I have mint, RHEL and windows 8 on my mbp and i used them all. All have strebgths and weaknesses.

      The rest i put in virtual machines.
      • .

        "It's all about choices right?"

    • So why the heck

      do you need 2 operating systems for??????
      • .

        You say why, I say why not? I like to use both Windows and Linux for different purpose.
        • I'm with you

          But I don't duel boot, I have an older Notebook on which I run Linux Mint 14! Windows 8 is on my main machine and even though I'm over 50 I've had no problems adapting to it. Works great! Choice, people is good I have no problems with anyone using what they want even if it's "SHUDDER" Apple OS X! ;-) lol
      • spoken like

        A true fan boy...
      • This is why

        If you have very strong preferences in applications, or an application that is simply the only choice for a highly specific task is only on a particular platform, you may need to have access to more than one platform.

        To draw on another type of computer, if your favorite games are those published by the console makers themselves, you're going to need multiple game consoles to run those exclusive items. If your tastes run more toward the stuff that is pretty much found everywhere, then nearly any machine will likely serve your desires.
      • I don't need 2 OS, I need about FOUR

        My preference is to run Windows 8 Pro natively and then VM OSX plus a couple of flavours of Linux using HyperV.
        Why? so I can run and support any application on any platform.
    • dual booting Windows 8 and Linux Mint

      is more like Heaven and Hell than different worlds.

      I'll leave it to others to decide which is which.
  • sooo

    Is this an article about Mint or bashing Win8?

    Sounds like they've done almost nothing new save for the widgets which everyone hates. This article was more about other operating systems, applications and hardware rather than the actual OS. The few points you did have you didn't like (widgets, no in place upgrade, Totem).

    How about actually mentioning what makes this distro so nice? There's nothing in this article that get's me excited about Mint, so either it's just another ho-hum release, or SJVN was way more concerned about bashing Windows than doing an article about his favorite Linux distro any justice.
    • Are you new here?

      "or SJVN was way more concerned about bashing Windows than doing an article about his favorite Linux distro any justice."

      That's pretty much all of his blog posts....
      • You really think so?

        You should see the comments regarding Linux and OSX reviews...
        "It's pretty much all the same..."
    • I found the grammar exciting

      "The easily way of installing Mint"
    • Both

      Steven is absolutely incapable of writing more than a paragraph or two without getting back onto the topic of how much he hates Windows. His hatred of Microsoft's OS defines his existence and he's generally unable to talk about anything else.
    • Windows 8 is only mentioned in passing

      Hardly a bash.
      John L. Ries
      • 6 times is, "in passing"?

        • But the focus of the article...

 Mint, not Windows 8. People are allowed to not like MS or Windows; and negative mentions of a commercial product do not constitute sacrelige (or even libel). Comparisons are appropriate.
          John L. Ries
          • Exactly the focus was...

            So why the need for 6 mentions? My statement had nothing to do with anyone liking any OS. The person I was replying to stated it was mentioned in passing.
            THAT WAS NOT TRUE.
            You can like and use whatever the hell you like, I could care less because I am going to do what is BEST FOR ME. Just don't try to say I stated any like or dislike for anything.
          • why mentioning Windows 8?

            Because this cr#$&*p is imposed on you when you buy almost any PC.