My first week with the Mac mini: First and lasting impressions from a Windows user gone awry

My first week with the Mac mini: First and lasting impressions from a Windows user gone awry

Summary: I've had my new Mac mini for exactly one week and it's been interesting. From frustration to happiness to buyer's remorse to searching for my Mac mojo groove, it's all here.

SHARE:
409

It's been a full week of Apple for me and an interesting one at that here at the Hess house. My family feels my pain. My new Mac mini is cool but I've discovered a few quirks with it that make me want my Windows system back. In all, I've almost duplicated everything from my old Windows computer to my mini, so there are only a few gaps that remain. In the midst of school starting, my own productivity needs, my birthday, and my daughter's birthday, and forcing myself to use the Mac mini exclusively, it's been a trying week.

I've used Windows for a long time. A really long time. Before that, I used DOS. During one of my breakups with Windows, I used Red Hat Linux as my workstation. I've always come back to Windows because, and I know how crazy this sounds to some of you, everything I do is just so much easier on a Windows system. Yes, that's right. I said it. Things are just easier to do in Windows.

Maybe it's just what I'm used to and maybe it's the way I work but, for me, Windows is easier to use, to manipulate, to be productive on, and so on.

Even way back in 1990, when I had a friend try to help me write up some documentation and create some graphics using a Mac, it was such a pain to use. Everything is so opposite from my way of thinking.

For example, when I click the X on an application, I expect it to exit. I don't expect it to still be open but on the Mac, it's still open. That weird application bar thing at the top is application focused. In other words, if you have an application open, Chrome, for example and you're browsing around and accidentally click on the background, you're now in Finder and your Chrome application bar disappears until you click on Chrome again.

That drives me bonkers.

And Macs used to only open that bar when you launched a program. You would see the application bar up there but nothing on the desktop. You had to click File->New to start a new document in Word. Maddening, I tell you, absolutely maddening. Thank goodness, they've fixed that.

When I click the X to close a program in Windows, it closes. It exits. No more of that program in memory. When I click the X in Linux, the same wonderous thing happens—program death.

I think this is why so many Mac users keep a lot of programs open—either they don't know or they don't care to close them. A similar thing happens on the iPad and iPhone. My daughter never quits any apps, so she always has twenty or more "minimized" apps on her devices. 

That also drives me bonkers.

Of course, everyone in my family also makes fun of me because I want them to close the doors when entering or leaving the house. I must be the one that's wrong. I like to close doors and apps. Deal with it.

So far this week, I've installed the Chrome browser, Microsoft Office, Skype, Pinta, VirtualBox, WireTap Studio, Xcode, Seashore, Monosnap, Jing, Janetter, Image Tricks Lite, Dropbox, and Audacity to get myself back to familiar territory.

Pinta is very much like Paint.NET, which I used a lot to create and edit graphics. It has a few missing elements and quirks that I don't like, so I'm still searching for a good alternative for an image editor. 

Chrome works better on the Mac than it does in Windows. I've complained about that before.

Audacity, Dropbox, VirtualBox, Skype, and MS Office all work pretty much the same on both platforms. If you haven't noticed, I really like free applications. I don't have the money to spend on dozens of apps to put myself back into the high-end computing saddle. Either I have to get complimentary apps for review, use free ones, or do without. 

That's one Windows criticism that I never understood. It comes relatively complete. There aren't many things that you have to go out and buy for it. Plus, if you need something, you can get it for free. The Mac, on the other hand, comes with very little in the way of pre-installed apps. You get Safari, Time Machine, and a few other utilities but that's about it. At the price that Apple charges ($800), you'd think I'd get a free copy of PhotoShop Lite or some other "lite" versions of something with it but, no, it's pretty bare bones.

My wife asked me yesterday, if there are any "big differences" in the two systems. I hesitated before I answered, which, if you know anything about women, it's always bad to do that. I answered, "Not really". I was honest. I don't really see a significant difference in the Windows system and this one—except that some of the apps I had on Windows either aren't available on Mac or that I have to rebuy them for the Mac.

That's the part that's giving me "Buyer's Remorse".

Read this

26 ways to improve your iPhone's battery life

26 ways to improve your iPhone's battery life

By applying a few system tweaks, you can improve your iPhone's battery life considerably.

If I'd bought a new Windows system, I could just reinstall everything to make my new system complete. With the Mac, I have to find "equivalent" apps. It doesn't always work.

Pinta, for example, won't allow me to cut or copy a bit of a drawing. I get an exception when I try. That's a significant fail for that product. I get some app crashes—far more than I should for a brand new system. So far, the App Store app has crashed multiple times, Pinta has crashed, and a few others that I can't recall have crashed on me. I always click "Send to Apple" on the little dialog box that pops up for what little good it will do me, but I still do it.

The reasons that I've always wanted a Mac seem a bit moot now. You see, I've always wanted a Mac for Desktop Publishing, for Graphics creation and editing, and for movie editing. All those things are now available for Windows and I'm not convinced that the Mac versions are any better these days. Twenty years ago, they were. Today, not so much.

I'm not disappointed with my new Mac but for the same amount of money, I could have had a super notebook, although not a Macbook Air, which as it turns out, I'm glad I didn't get because of my buyer's remorse. I'd have probably returned the Air by now, whereas I'm on the fence about the mini.

Some things are harder to do on the Mac and nothing so far has been easier. Thank goodness that many of my favorite applications are available on all platforms. If Chrome weren't available for the Mac, I wouldn't still be using it at all. I spend a lot of time in Chrome because I use GMail and no other browser does it justice. So Chrome would have been a real deal breaker for me had it not worked.

On the plus side, iMovie and Garage Band both come standard on the Mac. iMovie is complete but I don't think my copy of Garage Band is. Either it's not complete or I can't make it work correctly. I have it on my iPad and it works fine, so I'm not sure that it's me.

I do wish that I could find a few good free or inexpensive apps for image editing that allows me to drag and drop text anywhere that I want to (I thought that was a Mac feature), a good image viewer (Preview sucks) that works like Windows Photo Viewer, and a good screen capture program like Camtasia. 

I did find a good online screenplay software program called Writer Duet that I really like. It's free and works as well as Celtx or Final Draft.

So, my opinion so far, for the first week is, I like the Mac mini. I don't love it. In fact, if I filled out a survey, I'd give it a 7 for overall satisfaction. And I probably wouldn't recommend it to anyone else if asked. I'd say stick with Windows. Stick with what you know.

I've worked with Linux, Windows, and Mac and, at this point in time, Windows still wins. For servers, it's a different discussion but for my personal desktop, I'll do Windows.

The bottom line is that working with a Mac and its quirks takes a little getting used to. The Mac isn't an iPad nor is it an iPhone. If I'm able to make the mini work, I'll use it for the balance of its life expectancy and then probably never use another Mac again. To prove my point, we just bought my daughter a new laptop for her birthday—an HP with Windows 8.

I'm thinking that I should have given her the mini and I could have had the new laptop. I have computer envy. 

But I'm going to stick with it. It's only been a week. I'll keep you updated but right now, I'm wondering if I made the right decision. If I'd bought a new Windows system, I'd still want a Mac. The mini was the least expensive way for me to find out that I'm really a PC guy.

What do you think? Am I having remorse because I don't have the apps that I need or is it something else? Talk back and let me know.

Related Stories:

Topics: Apple, Linux, Microsoft, Windows

About

Kenneth 'Ken' Hess is a full-time Windows and Linux system administrator with 20 years of experience with Mac, Linux, UNIX, and Windows systems in large multi-data center environments.

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily email newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.

Talkback

409 comments
Log in or register to join the discussion
  • Fantastic article

    Loved reading it.

    Made popcorn.

    This will be good.

    *munch* *munch*
    toddbottom3
    • @toddbottom3

      LOL. If we teamed up toddbottom3, I think we could conquer the world. We'd split it 60/40. I'm being generous.
      khess
      • Why would you team up with a person who has no respect for the dead?

        I wonder what people would think if I used this picture as an avatar?

        http://www.eazytek.com/gallery/v/hurleys/computers/gates_hitler.jpg.html
        Arm A. Geddon
        • Respect is earned

          It must be earned while alive. Death does not grant anyone respect.

          As for your avatar, go for it. I wouldn't complain. In fact, where did you think I got the idea for mine? You guys have been extremely disrespectful of Gates and Ballmer and that's just fine, this is a free country.
          toddbottom3
          • Disrespectful of Gates and Ballmer?

            Really? Show me of any of my posts that did. Just like Ballmers retirement. Nothing said. Don't care. Same as with Gates. Nothing. Neither pays my bills.
            Arm A. Geddon
          • But Matt

            I mean todd worships Microsoft every day. He prays in the direction of Redmond, 5 times a day like the followers of Microislam are required to.
            Troll Hunter J
          • Do you understand the meaning of the word?

            So let me try to view the world through your unique perspective.

            In your mind the following profile deserves no respect:

            - A man who built the most valuable company in the world from a garage.
            - A man who created the most successful and valued 3D studio in the world.
            - A man who reinvented the PC several times through his career.
            - A man who's technologies where copied by the largest tech players.
            - A man who changed the way we purchase and listen to music.
            - A man who changed the way we use our cell phones and set the model for all other to follow.
            - A man who brought about the mobile computing revolution.
            - A man who was able to bridge the creative world with the technical world.

            These feats, that only a hand full of people in the history of mankind can claim to have had the same impact on the world, has not earned respect.

            Wow....someone somewhere at some time really did a number on you kid, to make your view of value so skewed and distorted. Normally I would just label someone with your metal limitations an imbecile and move on but I really can't do that to you. To ridicule someone with your special needs would just be cruel, I truly hope you can find help some day. You have earned my pity.
            KBabcock75
          • @KBabcock75 Using your logic.

            Using your logic. At the height of the Third Reich, Adolph Hitler was also deserving of admiration, reverence and respect. Get real, Jobs was an A hole and was known for treating people like shi*. And also known for stealing other peoples ideas and claiming them as his own. And speaking of which, you act like he invented all this stuff.
            j-mccurdy@...
          • Hmm...

            Excuse me, but what did YOU invent during your lifetime?Even based on others inventions?You know,something valuable? Something, whole the mankind would appreciate?
            Maria Davidenko
          • You could be talking about either Jobs or Gates!

            BTW, they both stole the "windows paradigm" from Xerox PARC. They were both geniuses and excellent businessmen.
            M Wagner
          • Gates still alive, no?

            :-)
            Maria Davidenko
        • They probably wouldn't think any less of you

          than they already do...besides, Hitler has been protrayed as every evil historic personality known to man, so that's nothing new. So I say go for it!

          Oh, my bad! You were referencing Bill Gates! Hmmm, I thought he was still alive, therefore in the minds of those offended by portrayals of dead personalities as something other than a deity, guess you wouldn't be making that much of a statement.
          wizard57m-cnet
          • Ouch

            I like your response far better than mine.

            Kudos.
            toddbottom3
        • What's even worse?

          A person who has no respect for the living.

          The dead don't very much care. The living do, especially if they are being unfairly disrespected.
          William Farrel
      • Thanks Ken

        I graciously decline the invitation but I will be voting for you as MS CEO. You don't even need to split anything with me.

        However, please continue with the blogging. ZDNet has been getting so good lately.
        toddbottom3
      • Don't feed the troll

        You would be feeding a troll if you team up with him. He's a fanatic anti Apple troll who only spew hates for just about anything other than MS ( don't get me wrong MS is a great company but could do without bias fanboy like him ). So why would you lower your standards for him. Mr Khess, you on the other hand is more fair and objectives in your reports. I can see your points regarding OS X. But sometimes it's just personal preference
        ThinkFairer8
        • Well...

          Maybe not?
          lelandhendrix@...
        • And the troll is....

          I find someone self-righteously writing about someone being a "MS fanboy or an Anti-Apple troll" is high comedy, since if you'd simply replace the word "Microsoft" with "Apple" or "Linux" and Windows with "OSX or whatever the Linux distro du-jour is", they'd be falling all over themselves fawning on the author for writing with insight and truth.
          jrbales@...
        • todd writes for ZDNet

          under the name "Matt Miller" Microsoft MVP, and Microsoft Mobius Mobile Evangelist.
          Troll Hunter J
    • let the Apple fanatics cry foul

      having used my wife's older Mac, my son's new HP with windows 8 and my desktop with windows 7, I'm DEFINITELY a Windows guy and always will be..
      dundonrl