Nokia steps up patent suit against HTC, targets HTC One

Nokia steps up patent suit against HTC, targets HTC One

Summary: Nokia adds another prong to its attack on Taiwanese handset maker HTC.


Nokia on Thursday filed a second complaint with the International Trade Commission (ITC) against HTC, claiming the Taiwanese smartphone company was shifting responsibility for infringement to its suppliers.

The Finnish handset maker's new ITC complaint adds another prong to it action against HTC and others it began last year.

"Nokia has filed further cases in the United States alleging that HTC products infringe additional Nokia patents," Nokia said in a statement to ZDNet.

"We began actions against HTC in 2012 to end the unauthorised use of our proprietary innovations and technologies. Since then, despite the German courts confirming infringements of Nokia patents in HTC products, HTC has shown no intention to end its practices, instead it has tried to shift responsibility to its suppliers. We have therefore taken these further steps to hold HTC accountable for its actions."

It's thought a number of patents are at issue in the case.  Patents blogger Florian Mueller has dug up the list of exhibits in the ITC complaint, which shows they relate to chips made by Broadcom and Qualcomm that feature in HTC's flagship One device. If the case is successful, it could lead to the affected devices, such as the HTC One, being banned from sale.

Nokia has also filed another suit against HTC in the US District Court for the Southern District of California San Diego. The suit covers three separate patents for a "terminal, method and computer program product for interacting with a signalling tag", which Nokia claims HTC infringes in ten smartphones, including its flagship HTC One and HTC First, the phone it adapted for use with Home for Facebook.

The two new suits cover nine patents and bring the total number to 50 that Nokia has contested in courts around the world, which have most recently played out through courts in Germany and the Netherlands. Meanwhile, the hearing for Nokia's other complaint at the ITC against HTC is expected to commence this month.

ZDNet has asked HTC for comment and will update the story if it receives one.

In response to the San Diego complaint, HTC told Bloomberg that "upon receiving the official document, HTC is to consider all legal options to protect our rights". 

Topics: Smartphones, Nokia, Patents

Liam Tung

About Liam Tung

Liam Tung is an Australian business technology journalist living a few too many Swedish miles north of Stockholm for his liking. He gained a bachelors degree in economics and arts (cultural studies) at Sydney's Macquarie University, but hacked (without Norse or malicious code for that matter) his way into a career as an enterprise tech, security and telecommunications journalist with ZDNet Australia. These days Liam is a full time freelance technology journalist who writes for several publications.

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily email newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.


Log in or register to join the discussion
  • I thought

    The majority of Nokia's patents were assigned (by Microsoft) to that Canadian Patent troll (MOSAID)?
    Troll Hunter J
  • Two losers duking it out ....

    over the scraps.

    Quite amusing in a way.
    • @D.T.Long

      Why waste your time posting if you're so superior ?? Lemme see .. Apple fanboi worried about declining market share or a Samsung pimp after another 5c from Korea ??

      Sounds more like Nokia clutching at straws again to me ...
      • Me superior to Nokia and HTC?

        I have never been compared to a corporation before, but:

        "Apple fanboi worried about declining market share or a Samsung pimp after another 5c from Korea ??"

        Don't own Apple products nor Samsung products.

        "Sounds more like Nokia clutching at straws again to me"

        So you making fun of Nokia only is somehow better than me poking fun at both Nokia and HTC?

        And exactly why did YOU "waste your time posting"?

        You do not know whether you are coming or going.
  • After Nokia won that patent battle in Germany, HTC does have reason to

    worry about its devices, and it's trying to pass on the battles and blame to its suppliers.

    Passing blame to others is a sign of culpability, and the suppliers were likely just following the requests and orders from HTC.
    • HTC is not at fault

      No matter how Nokia looks at it, the suppliers that have a contract with Nokia are at fault. If a supplier sells something that is owned and patented by another company, then that manufacturer is at fault. It's a bad case of "the middle man screwed up".
  • Samsung will be happy....

    If Nokia wins and HTC Ones are banned [unlikely though].