Not really 'flat rate'? German court trips up Deutsche Telekom's throttling plans

Not really 'flat rate'? German court trips up Deutsche Telekom's throttling plans

Summary: Many customers would have had their DSL speeds cut to 2Mbps after they reached a 75GB cap.

SHARE:
3

Deutsche Telekom's plans to introduce throttling for heavy users appears to have run into difficulties.

A regional court in Germany ruled on Wednesday that throttling broadband connections would put Deutsche Telekom's customers at an "unreasonable disadvantage". The telco recently announced plans to limit users' broadband speeds to 2Mbps after they exceeded specified monthly download limits, starting at 75GB for some plans. The caps were scheduled to come into force in 2016.

The court ruling came in response to a case brought by consumer group Verbraucherzentrale Nordrhein-Westfalen, which claimed that there was no valid legal basis for capping the speeds. However, to some degree the ruling seemed to hinge on semantics: in a statement, the court noted that if Deutsche Telekom customers sign up for "flat rate" plans, they expect "a fixed price for a certain surfing speed, and do not expect limitations". All of the telco's DSL plans are marketed as "flat rate".

The ruling also noted that in an era of streaming television and films, 2Mbps was simply too restrictive for many users, challenging Deutsche Telekom's assertion that the throttling would only affect what it referred to as 'power users'.

Initially, the telco planned on throttling speeds to 384Kbps, but raised the rates to 2Mbps in response to criticism. Even so, the plans continued to draw consumers' ire, including a Change.org petition that garnered more than 200,000 signatures from angry customers.

In response to the criticism, Deutsche Telekom noted that since the throttling would only start at 75GB, most users — who currently use between 15GB to 20GB per month, according to the telco — would not have been affected.

This month, fellow German broadband provider O2 introduced new plans to throttle broadband connections across the country. Starting next year, many customers will see their internet speeds drop to 2Mbps when they reach a 300GB limit for the fourth straight month.

In advertising and promotional materials, O2 also positions most of its internet plans as "flat rate".

The Deutsche Telekom court decision is appealable. "We cannot understand the decision," said a Deutsche Telekom spokesperson. "We will review the ruling, and expect to appeal."

Further reading

Topics: Broadband, Networking, Telcos, EU

Michael Filtz

About Michael Filtz

From the day he brought home a modem and dialed in to a local BBS in 1991, Michael has been obsessed with technology and how it enables collaboration. He has a master's degree in journalism from UC Berkeley, and has worked in and around the technology start-up scenes in San Francisco and Berlin.

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily email newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.

Talkback

3 comments
Log in or register to join the discussion
  • 2 Mbps not enough???

    2 Mbps is superfast in US. Unless you are running a website business you don't need that.
    LlNUX Geek
    • you're living in the past

      almost any cable or FiOS service is way faster than that
      I like my 75 Mbps service
      andycher2
  • ruling is useless

    They will just change the plans and pricing instead of capping. They weren't going to change anything until 2016 so they have time to figure it out.
    Net-Tech_z