Production of low-cost 'iPhone 5C' draws allegations of poor working conditions

Production of low-cost 'iPhone 5C' draws allegations of poor working conditions

Summary: A recently leaked photo suggests that the low-cost iPhone will be marketed as the iPhone 5C, but what the "C" stands for may surprise you.

TOPICS: Apple, Hardware, iPhone

It appears that the widely rumored, low-cost iPhone will be sold as the "iPhone 5C" if recently leaked photos are real. 

French site posted an image from Chinese site WeiPhone that appears to show plastic retail packaging emblazoned with the name "iPhone 5C." If genuine, it could be upcoming packaging for Apple's rumored low-cost, plastic iPhone. 

The "C" doesn't stand for Cheap, China or Child Labor, but instead for "Colors" according to the consensus at MacRumors. The low-cost device, believed to be targeted at emerging economies in BRIC countries (Brazil, Russia, India and China) will be priced less than the forthcoming iPhone 5S and will presumably include less-expensive CPU, camera and networking hardware and lower-cost materials. 

Computerworld published a 60-page report (PDF) from labor rights group China Labor Watch alleging poor working conditions also confirms that a plastic-shelled iPhone is currently in mass production at Pegatron. A section of the report entitled "July 9, 2013: A day in Pegatron" includes a paragraph in which a worker describes their role in applying protective film to the rear shell of the device before the part enters the assembly process.

Today’s work is to paste protective film on the iPhone’s plastic back cover to prevent it from being scratched on assembly lines. This iPhone model with a plastic cover will soon be released on the market by Apple. The task is pretty easy, and I was able to work independently after a five-minute instruction from a veteran employee. It took around a minute to paste protective film on one rear cover. The new cell phone has not yet been put into mass production, so quantity is not as important. This makes our job more slow paced than in departments that have begun mass production schedules.

Pictures of what's believed to be rear shells of the iPhone 5C have previously leaked, showing that the device will come in five colors including red, yellow, white, blue and green.

Apple's low-cost, plastic iPhone 5C colors - Jason O'Grady

More seriously, Pegatron is accused of misleading Apple on employee overtime.

Pegatron has a falsified attendance recording system in which workers’ overtime is recorded to be less than the real amount. Each week, all workers are required by an HR assistant to check yes and sign their names on an overtime form. Workers are required to sign and are not to pay attention to the number of overtime hours written on the form; the document’s only purpose is to deceive Apple during inspections.

Other claimed violations according to China Labor Watch:

  • Dispatch labor abuse,
  • Hiring discrimination,
  • Women’s rights violations,
  • Contract violations,
  • Insufficient worker training,
  • Excessive working hours,
  • Insufficient wages,
  • Poor working conditions,
  • Poor living conditions,
  • Difficulty in taking leave,
  • Labor health and safety concerns,
  • Ineffective grievance channels,
  • Abuse by management,
  • Environmental pollution.

You can read the report in its entirety here (PDF)

Topics: Apple, Hardware, iPhone

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily email newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.


Log in or register to join the discussion
  • Consumers want cheap stuff

    But when normal moral rules are not respected, each consumer should try to make a little bit of justice.
    When it's cheap clothes I can almost understand poor working conditions, but it's a big no no with luxury products and I'm sure the "cheap iPhone" is not going to be cheap.
  • That Must Be A Joke

    iPhone 5C?
    The obvious association with "C" for "CHEAP" is way to easy.
    Apple would never go there... At least I think.
    • Typo

      I meant "too" easy.
      • And Thanks ZDNet...

        For not allowing us to edit our posts.
  • What a shock

    Apple have to keep the margins up somehow.
  • Moto X

    Good for Motorola/Google to bring smartphone manufacturing to the US. Hopefully it will be priced competitively and be a good design. Unfortunately if it comes down to price vs morality price will win.
    • Assembled

      I should clarify that the Moto X ads say "assembled" not manufactured in the US.
  • Oh the irony

    We have been hearing iSheep cry "Cheap Plastic Samsung" for years, and now what does Apple do? They make a cheap plastic phone for the iSheep to eat their words with! I can't wait to see them all try to walk backwards and talk This one up when Apple releases this phone! I'm sure they will drink this kool-aid and backtrack, but how hard will it be for them? Time will tell.