Russian teacher wins software licensing case

Russian teacher wins software licensing case

Summary: Alexander Ponosov is celebrating after a court threw out claims that he deliberately used unlicensed Microsoft software in a Russian school

TOPICS: Networking

The case against a Russian schoolteacher who was accused of using unlicensed software in the classroom has been thrown out, following international attention and an intervention from former Soviet leader Mikhail Gorbachev.

On Thursday, a Russian court rejected the case against Alexander Ponosov, labelling it "trivial", according to the Associated Press. Ponosov told AP that he was "off to drink champagne" following the decision.

Ponosov was accused of using unlicensed versions of Windows operating system and Microsoft Office on 12 PCs. But he insisted that he had bought the computers with the software already installed, and had no idea there might be a problem.

Under Russia's intellectual property laws, Ponosov could have been sentenced to five years imprisonment if found guilty. The prosecution, though, had been seeking a fine of 3,000 rubles (£58.50), and claimed that Microsoft had suffered 267,000 rubles of damage.

The case was brought by Russian authorities but brought criticism against Microsoft, which is pushing for tougher action against software "pirates" globally. Microsoft has denied being involved in the case.

As reported last week, Gorbachev wrote a letter to Microsoft chairman Bill Gates, arguing that Ponosov who is from a remote village in the Urals, should be shown mercy because he did not know he was committing a crime.

Topic: Networking

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily email newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.


1 comment
Log in or register to join the discussion
  • 10,000 USD is trivial?

    I am not sure that you properly interpret this as "the teacher wins". As far as I understand the original Russian text (and I am Russian), the real situation is much more interesting. The court have decided that the teacher is guilty but the damage amount (about 10,000 USD) is "trivial" for MSFT, and, thereby, the teacher may go away without any penalties.

    Does it mean that everyone in Russia may use non-lisensed MS or Adobe software without major problems if the total software cost is below 10,000 USD? Not necessary so, because Russian law system is not based on precendents. But it looks like that we have a chance :-)