Sprint's Clearwire acquisition in trouble as Softbank caps bid

Sprint's Clearwire acquisition in trouble as Softbank caps bid

Summary: In a game of acquisition chicken, Sprint wants to buy Clearwire, but Clearwire's shareholders are rejecting the initial offer. Softbank, meanwhile, is refusing to raise Sprint's offer.


On Thursday, Sprint offered $2.1 billion to buy the remaining shares it doesn't currently own in rival cellular network Clearwire.

The Sprint-Clearwire deal would see the 11 million subscriber-strong cellular network snapped up by the U.S.' third largest network for $2.90 a share for the remaining 48.3 percent of Clearwire shares that Sprint does not yet own, along with a $800 million cash injection to help keep Clearwire afloat.

Read this

Sprint offers $2.1bn to claim full ownership of Clearwire

Sprint offers $2.1bn to claim full ownership of Clearwire

Clearwire rockets in pre-market trading following an offer from Sprint to buy out the remaining stake in Clearwire for around $2.1 billion.

The share buy-out deal was already 5 percent higher than Clearwire's closing share price on Wednesday.

But on news of the deal, Clearwire shares rocketed by almost 15 percent to $3.16 on the news, sending a strong signal that investors wanted more out of the deal. Reuters now reports that Clearwire investors are thinking exactly along those lines and want more out of the deal.

But there's a problem.

Sprint announced in October that it would sell a 70 percent stake in the company to Japan's Softbank for $20.1 billion. In return, Sprint will receive $8 billion of new capital for investment back into its mobile network. As we now know, this was partially to buy out Clearwire in order to gain more customers and to expand its network, along with other investments.

Here's where the domino effect comes into play. Softbank owns a majority chunk of Sprint, and Sprint wants the remaining shares of Clearwire, but Softbank ultimately -- as it is the majority shareholder in Sprint -- has to approve any Clearwire takeover.

So long as nobody wanted more, the deal probably could have gone ahead without any of the companies involved suffering any major headaches.

However, Clearwire shareholders -- who own about 7.6 percent of the company -- criticized the Sprint offer and wanted at least $5 a share, pushing Clearwire's valuation at roughly $7.3 billion, or three-times more than the initial asking price. 

Softbank, however, has capped the bid that Sprint can offer to $2.97 per share, or $4.34 billion, according to two sources speaking to the Reuters news agency. Softbank's cap leaves the Clearwire bid short of about $3 billion. 

It's a game of buy-out chicken. Now it's just a case of who will buckle under the pressure of the potential sale: Softbank may raise its bid but can't look like a pushover, while Clearwire can't survive in the long-term but can't push its asking price too high or it may lose out on non-banking financing.

But Clearwire, at this point, cannot be too picky on the details and may have to ultimately succumb to a price lower than what the company's share price reflects. Clearwire is struggling and requires financing to upgrade its infrastructure to keep its 11 million subscribers connected, and ultimately keep the company afloat. Reuters says the company has enough money to "last until the third quarter" of 2013.

Crest Financial, which owns more than 3 percent of Clearwire, said it "intends to take whatever actions it can" to avoid "unfair dealing by Sprint and other parties," while the financial firm's lawsuit continues on in a bid to prevent a deal between Sprint and Clearwire.

We've put in questions to both Sprint and Clearwire, but did not hear back outside U.S. business hours. If we hear back, we'll update the piece.

Topics: Telcos, 4G, Government US, Networking, Smartphones

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily email newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.


Log in or register to join the discussion
  • Sprint really need to crap or get off the pot

    Sprint success is simple build your LTE 4G out with complete unrelenting diligent or die. Get err done! Sprint cannot fool around any longer this is it for their customer base. Their success has hinged only on their unlimited plans that others do not offer at any reasonable price points. Sprint customers have held on only by that preverbal string and that string is about to break. Sprint customers have had enough and loyalty is becoming a thing of the past. Simple they want they where promised LTE 4G in their markets and it has to happen yesterday or resigns are not going to happen this time around.
  • already gone

    I've already decided to leave Sprint for Verizon. Though I will no longer have unlimited data and the plan prices are higher, I will have better service. I'll be able to walk into a store, and not lose signal. I'll be able to browse at the faster 4G speeds. Plus, I've wanted a Windows phone but Sprint has yet to pick any up. As for losing unlimited data, I don't use that much anyways. A 4 gig plan for my wife and me will be plenty. With Verizon, our price will only increase by about $10 a month. Well worth it when you consider the better coverage and faster speeds. So long Sprint.