The battle over virtual machine software

The battle over virtual machine software

Summary: Although some believe that virtual machine software, the hypervisor, has become a commodity and is no longer interesting, many suppliers are battling to be the dominant supplier of this technology. They hope to bring customers into their ecosystem and hold them there. Does the hypervisor matter any more?

SHARE:
TOPICS: Virtualization
6

The hypervisor battle continues even though many in the industry believe that virtual machine software has become a commodity and it really matters little which hypervisor is selected. The companies offering virtual machine software are trying to add features and functions to their technology that will tie users into their own ecosystem of tools and add-ons, and will make their software handle larger and smaller workloads gracefully.

What is VMS?

As defined in my book Virtualization: A Manager's Guide, Virtual Machine Software is one of five different forms of Processing Virtualization. Here's a quote from the book:

Virtual machine software allows the entire stack of software that makes up a system to be encapsulated into a virtual machine file. Then a hypervisor can run one or more complete virtual systems on a physical machine. There are two types of hypervisors: A type 1 hypervisor runs on top of the physical system. A type 2 hyper- visor allows a guest system to run as a process under another operating system. Each of these systems processes as if it has total control of its own system, even though it may only be using a portion of the capabilities of a larger physical system.

The goal here is to encapsulate a complete system image and allow it to execute side by side with other virtual machines on a single physical system. Virtual machines are not aware of others executing on the same physical machine. They can be moved from one physical machine to another or from one data center to another to improve levels of workload reliability, make a workload more disaster tolerant, and provide protection from outside interference.

Companies offering VMS

Virtual Machine Software is available from the following companies and open source communities.

General purpose VMS

  • The KVM community includes Red Hat, IBM, and most Linux distributions
  • Microsoft offers Hyper-V, its own VMS
  • The Xen community includes Citrix, Oracle, and most Linux distributions
  • VMware offers vSphere, its own VMS

Special purpose VMS

If we look around a bit, we'll also discover that a number of companies are offering small, limited purpose VMS products that are sometimes described as “microvisors.” They include the following:

  • Bromium is offering a vSentry, a VMS designed to isolate components of applications and the applications themselves to offer heightened levels of security and control for PC applications.
  • Piston Cloud is offering Iocane, a VMS designed to secure cloud computing resources by offering them a tightly controlled, secure computing environment.

Why should we care what VMS is being used?

All of the virtual machine software products are the focus of a great deal of engineering talent. Their ability to support greater amounts of physical and virtual memory is one area of this focus. Allowing applications to execute using a number of cores or processors to improve overall performance is another – today's VMS products can present the image of having 16, 32, or even 64 processors dedicated to an application. The number and performance of networking devices is another area of intense focus. The same can be said of virtual storage available to the application. The availability of highly granular management and security are still other areas of focus.

Each supplier is trying to engage software and hardware suppliers in the hopes of creating an “all-encompassing” ecosystem which would encourage customers to select their technology over that offered by other suppliers or communities.

Analysis

Enterprises today often have workloads supported by a number of different VMS products even if they had a commitment to a single product. The purchase of packaged software that was designed for another VMS is one reason this occurs. Another reason is that an enterprise may have acquired another and the other company had standardized on a dfferent product. As long as things are working, there is little incentive to change something that is at such a low level in the software stack.

It would be wise for organizations to understand that each VMS product is likely to offer a different list of benefits and restrictions. The organization could then select the best VMS product to satisfy the requirements of any given workload.

Topic: Virtualization

About

Daniel Kusnetzky, a reformed software engineer and product manager, founded Kusnetzky Group LLC in 2006. He's literally written the book on virtualization and often comments on cloud computing, mobility and systems software. In his spare time, he's also the managing partner of Lux Sonus LLC, an investment firm.

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily email newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.

Talkback

6 comments
Log in or register to join the discussion
  • Is this still relevant?

    I have used VMware for many years as a consumer, so when I recently had the need to virtualize a few servers, I naturally turned to them for my virtualization needs. After a bit of a learning curve, I got pleasing results from using their hypervisor on my hardware.

    As I was doing it, one of my friends questioned why I was using that approach at all rather than using ready-made cloud-based solutions from Amazon, Microsoft, and Google. He believes that it will simply be faster to use them for projects that need to be launched or scale quickly. I haven't done the dollar comparison of the two methods, but he might be right.

    Do you think that cloud-based virtualization solutions may eventually make all of these hypervisors niche products someday?
    the.ksmm
    • Good question

      And one I thought the author might address. This article was written as though for a question on Ask.com on "what is VMS"? But not for the type of technically educated crowd we have here on Zdnet. That or for advertising that the author had written a book on the topic.
      It would have been more interesting if the focus were the question that you asked.
      Huckleseed
    • Eventually

      I can see that it may happen eventually but for now debugging "in the cloud" is pretty much a non-starter unless you've got the most awesome instrumentation money can buy with further custom bits of your own. For now, hybrid seems to be the solution even if the local part has but one or a fer servers as hosts.
      Brian J. Bartlett
      • The first use of IaaS cloud services for many is dev/test

        When I speak with mid market and larger organizations, often they tell me the first use they make of cloud computing is making use of a IaaS solution for development and testing. This way, they can have the configuration they want without having to go through a purchasing cycle; have space in their data center for the systems, networking and storage; and can walk away from it at the end of their testing.

        I guess that they have worked out how to make this work for them.

        Dan K
        dkusnetzky
    • Eventually

      I can see that it may happen eventually but for now debugging "in the cloud" is pretty much a non-starter unless you've got the most awesome instrumentation money can buy with further custom bits of your own. For now, hybrid seems to be the solution even if the local part has but one or a few servers as hosts.
      Brian J. Bartlett
    • No, not really

      Cloud computing's infrastructure as a service is just moving your workloads to someone else's data center. It can be seen as a form of outsourcing. Moving workloads to a cloud service provider's data center can mean that the organization has just given up its right to choose and decided to be happy with what they're given. Depending upon the service provider, VMware, Xen, or KVM are likely to be in use.
      dkusnetzky