ie8 fix
Click Here

EU to probe Facebook over facial recognition feature

By | June 8, 2011, 8:28am PDT

Summary: The European Union is unhappy with the fact that Facebook turned on Tag Suggestions, a facial recognition feature, by default without notifying users first.

European Union data-protection regulators are planning to probe Facebook over its latest facial recognition feature that it began rolling out worldwide yesterday. Facebook rolled out Tag Suggestions across the US late last year, but for countries outside of the US, the company switched it on by default without telling its users first.

“Tags of people on pictures should only happen based on people’s prior consent and it can’t be activated by default,” Gerard Lommel, a Luxembourg member of the so-called Article 29 Data Protection Working Party, told BusinessWeek. Such automatic tagging “can bear a lot of risks for users” and the group of European data protection officials will “clarify to Facebook that this can’t happen like this.”

When you upload new photos, Facebook uses software similar to that found in many photo editing tools to match your new photos to other photos you’re tagged in. Similar photos are grouped together and, whenever possible, Facebook suggests the name(s) your friend(s) in the photos. In other words, the square that magically finds faces in a photo now suggests names of your Facebook friends to streamline the tagging process, especially with the same friends in multiple uploaded photos.

When I asked Facebook about the feature yesterday, I was given the following statement: “We launched Tag Suggestions to help people add tags of their friends in photos; something that’s currently done more than 100 million times a day. Tag Suggestions are only made to people when they add new photos to the site, and only friends are suggested. If for any reason someone doesn’t want their name to be suggested, they can disable the feature in their Privacy Settings. When we announced this feature last December, we explained that we would test it, listen to feedback and iterate before rolling it out more broadly. We should have been more clear with people during the roll-out process when this became available to them. Tag Suggestions are now available in most countries and we’ll post further updates to our blog over time.”

For more information about Tag Suggestions and how turn them off, check out yesterday’s article: Facebook starts rolling out facial recognition feature worldwide.

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily e-mail newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.

Topics

Emil Protalinski has covered the tech industry for five years for multiple publications.

Disclosure

Emil Protalinski

Emil has nothing to disclose.

Biography

Emil Protalinski

Emil Protalinski has covered the tech industry for five years for multiple publications, including Neowin for two years and Ars Technica for three years. He has written 1,000s of articles for both, with a particular focus on scrutinizing Microsoft products and services. Recently, Emil has expanded his coverage to non-Microsoft technologies, including the social networking giant Facebook.

49
Comments

Join the conversation!

Just In

RE: EU to probe Facebook over facial recognition feature
FAULKNE 13th Oct
Good day to confirm this comment I would appreciate T h e b e s t o f Z D N e t d e l i v e r e d your website very nice to everyone Yes, Oracle is the only one with shared-disk architecture, but that is there advantage. It means you can add or remove nodes and the database lives on. In a shared nothing architecture, if you lose a node, you lose the system. I'm sure Oracle appreciates EMC highlighting their advantage.I also desire to signal in your RSS feeds. Thank you as soon as once again and maintain up the great operate Awesome post! Thank you very much || thanks for nice content this is really benefit to me.
0 Votes
+ -
about time
tatiGmail 8th Jun
its about time Facebook was told they are not immune to law.
0 Votes
+ -
@tatiGmail

It's amazing how much trouble FB would save themselves if these new features were set to "off" by default instead of "on".
@OffsideInVancouver

It is more amazing how few people would use these features if they were not defaulted to on. For example, in many European countries, being an organ donor is automatic unless you opt out. These countries tend to have greater than 90% enrollment. In the US, being an organ donor is opt in, we have something like 15%. (Apologies for being too lazy to look up the exact numbers.)

Opt in seldom draws a significant crowd.
@jdakula: But in many cases it's the right thing to do. If someone were given the choice presented up front and would say no, then not presenting that choice directly (facebook didn't exactly have a huge press conference about this feature) then it's deceptive. I hadn't heard about the feature until I read about how creepy it is in the news... Facebook didn't make an effort to inform me that it existed as a user.
@OffsideInVancouver

2 REASONS...
1. THEY WOULDN'T MAKE ADVERTISING $$$$$
2. THE GOV'T WOULDN'T BE ABLE TO STORE DATA OF
ITS CITIZENS WITHOUT OUR KNOWLEDGE!
0 Votes
+ -
Life's not black and white
acrazysailor@... 8th Jun
@tatiGmail
The feature should be on by default. The first time it's used, there should be a box or popup or notification saying, "this is a new feature!, do you like it?: yes or no. If you need to turn it on/off later go to Privacy settings -> face recognition and toggle the button."
End of argument. They get their 90% sign up rates or nearly that and you get the choice. Soooo simple.
@acrazysailor@... They can have a banner pop up advising the availability of the feature and an opt in option by default. No privacy invasion no hassle unless you want in.
Simpler, smarter by half and morally and legally acceptable.
@tatiGmail

Down with Facebook! They aren't the only ones that think they're immune. Corporations in general have too much power and its time they all get a reality check!
@tatiGmail

This is why people I know have stopped using FB...

I do the best to protect my privacy and those of my children on the internet....
THIS IS WHY I WILL NEVER PLACE PHOTOS OF MY FAMILY ON FB !!!
0 Votes
+ -
Facebook = Creepybook
vanarie 8th Jun
Who needs NSA/CIA working on domestic surveillance when you have everyone using Facebook! Fb is capturing all your communications, social connections, chat history and facial biometrics BY DEFAULT. But how cares, FB is FREE! Woohoo!
@vanarie Everyone? The millions of users FB reports is a prodyct of imagination. Some probably sign up and then never go back again. Nobody knows how many real active users they have.
@vanarie Well, it's already happening in some countries, including mine, where FB comments are now being deemed a threat to national security and people here have been charged with sedition....but hey, like you said, FB is free innit?
0 Votes
+ -
Unspoken Consent?
Zagsforlife 8th Jun
I remember this feature magically appearing, and didn't give it a second thought. I guess I have come to expect Facebook's seamless integration of new features, while neglecting the importance of my consent!!
The real issue here is that people who are NOT facebook members but who have friends who are members may end up tagged and in pictures online... eliminating their privacy without their approval (as they can't opt-out of a function on a site they don't even use).

Now pedophiles can find pictures of my daughters on my sister-in-law's page, complete with names. From that they can derive enough information to locate, approach, and perhaps kidnap one of them. Things like this have already happened.

Even if you practice safe computing habits, does EVERYONE you know and interact with? If not, facebook is a danger to you too... even if you're not a member.

Sorry for the rant, but I appear to be on a privacy kick today.

Regards,
Jon
@JonathonDoe Ummm...no....if you are not a member you cannot be tagged. That said...FB can take a long walk off a short pier....don't trust them at all.
@ColdFusion_z
You can't be tagged by users, true. But I have no doubt that Facebook is still cataloging who it thinks it sees in every picture uploaded.

Not so sure I'd be worried about the pedophile though.
@ColdFusion_z What stops it? I am not a FB user; some in my family are. Family member X posts a photo that includes me and names everyone it. Good ol' X posts another photo that I'm also in. What stops FB from tagging it via the recognition process?
@JonathonDoe

I 1,0000% agree with you..My twins are 2yrs old..I WILL NEVER place photos of them on FB or any other site.

Friends have asked for me to do so, I have politely explained my privacy/safety issues and said I will gladly send them to your personal e-mail address just not on FB regardless of how safe they claim their settings are.
0 Votes
+ -
There is an alternative
OnlyMeWorld.com 8th Jun
Don't you think it's funny our government can't even obtain this kind of information about it's citizens without a court order, but facebook and other social networking site have been given the latitude? Why not, for the government it'll be like going to the library and avoid dealing with the ACLU, Lawsuits, etc., Wait is this the facebook that has like buttons all over the web and can track your whereabouts? Not the same facebook that bowed to china, and doesn't allow it's chinese users to talk about politics and religion is it? OnlyMeWorld.com the new alternative to facebook. No Real Names, No Email!
Just a thought. Facebook is not a mandatory software that people have to use by law. Everyone seems to think these things are against them and not for the benefit of Facebook. If people don't like it turn it off or hey don't even sign up for the service. EU is always suing some American Company. If I was Microsoft I would say the license agreement on MS is null and you can't use any of our software anywhere in Europe. Go back to DOS. Same with Google, Apple, Linux, etc. These lawsuits and multi million$ fines have to stop. Make it something real and worthwhile and software companies get a backbone and hit the Socialist back.
@GAstorino@... Socialist? Please define that word for us as you obviously have no idea what it means. I use FB because it's the most effective method for me to communicate with the large family and even larger group of friends I have from childhood. Not to mention the dozen or so people I have met in the computing community around the world. Just because we use their site doesn't give them the right to ignore major privacy concerns. Watch the movie, the kid that "created" Fb was an arrogant ass from the start. I'm guessing some money was passed during the original lawsuits against him, otherwise he would have lost those cases. Too bad, too, because maybe he would have learned a little humility and gotten some sense.
Yes, I can email my friends and family to stay in touch. And I do. But FB is the easiest way to share thoughts and ideas to a large group that I have found. Myspace used to be a clearinghouse for malware of all sorts, and I hold a grudge there, so I won't use them.
I'm guessing you were probably completely against the antitrust suit that the justice department filed against MS.
I have an idea. Why don't you come up with "the next greatest thing in computing" and decide to not market it to the second or thirds largest consumer base on the planet and see how far it gets.
@digital riverrat Sorry...that "large family" stuff is hooey....use e-mail.....and a photo sharing site....job done and you are in control. People are too friggin lazy these days and that is why FB exists....too lazy to e-mail your family...brutal folks!!
@GAstorino@... Oh Wow. Tell us what you really think. The EU does go overboard at times, true, but the US Justice Dept, is not much diffrerent in that respect
Oops! We should have been more clear that we were going to tags your pics without your consent. But now that we know who you are we are trustworthy enough to safegaurd this information.....
Facebook is an invention and investment of the CIA!
Theres no way that FB had enough critical mass and funding to grow this size...
Euro pervs worried having their hangups and mistresses outed !.
WA WA WA !!!
WHAT IF I GET FACE SURGERY!!?!?!?!
0 Votes
+ -
Facebook Facial Recognition
shrecewa 8th Jun
Don't use the service if you don't like it! Afterall, you aren't paying anything for it!
@shrecewa
DUH.
I'm sure no one here would have thought of that had you not told us. lol
how is it an invasion?
don't you already know who your friends are?
can't you remember what they look like?
from what i can see if they arn't in your friends list they don't get tagged.
it is simply automating what people do manually now.
if i tag a photo with the wrong name i dont know until a friend rings me up(friends do that you know) and tells me they are better looking than that!!!
0 Votes
+ -
@Esckay
I don't tag friends in photos. I let them tag themselves. I do so because I don't want being tagged in their photos. That said, recently, I uploaded a couple photos, and lo and behold, this ever-helpful (*sarcasm*) feature chimes in, asking me to tag any and all faces it can find. And I had those privacy settings off already. How's that for invasion?
0 Votes
+ -
EU?
ADboy 8th Jun
Does the EU have nothing better to do and go after American Companies? I think that they make this up to give themselves some more job to do so that the commission employees don't loose jobs.
0 Votes
+ -
what's the problem?
tsg1971 8th Jun
I'm often frustrated by the way Facebook tends to introduce new features. But in this case I don't really understand the fuss.

It only suggests tags on YOUR photos for YOUR friends. Something (if you tag photos anyway) that you would probably do. It's a time-saver and nothing more. It would have been more user-friendly to provide a notice the first time, but I don't see anything particularly bad about the feature in general.
This is a very useful feature and have save me loads of time and effort over the last couple of days.

I have not worries about privacy, and I always thought it was a wast of time me tagging photos myself when I know that there technology out there to do it automatically.

So I just thought Facebook finally caught up with the times.
I believe FB just needs to market better their new features instead of 'on by default'. I mean, why not a box called "New Features" somewhere in the main page?
100% FB IS SELLING 2 VERY DARK SIDE 1000%
jdakula:
I value my privacy and right to decide what happens to the remains of myself, my wife and children.
NO GOV'T HAS THE RIGHT to decide what is done with MY REMAINS!!!!

I am not against being a donor..Some religions have certain laws when it comes to burial.
FaceBook is like an internet, schoolyard bully. It will keep poking and proding and irritating just to see what it can get away with before someone in authority sits them in a corner. Zuckerberg is a self-centered dick.
I also desire to signal in your RSS feeds. Thank you as soon as once again and maintain up the great operate! nccma cooler
I used to be more than happy to seek out this internet-site.I wanted to thanks in your time for this glorious read!! I positively enjoying each little bit of it and I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff you weblog post. this thread is amazing i like your work and i appreciate you that you have share a useful stuff thanks for sharing the i shop abatwa
I used to be more than happy to seek out this internet-site.I wanted to thanks in your time for this glorious read!! I positively enjoying each little bit of it and I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff you weblog post.Bookmarking now thanks please consider a follow up post. power sa shop
I think the representation of this article is actually superb one. This is my first visit to your site. Thanks a lot and keep sharing the information. Keep updating the information for all of us. Thanks ZDNet Government was launched as the brand's first industry vertical, with a mission to cater to IT professionals in the public secto I agree with your post. However, do you have any sources I can cite for my paper wheel car com bury
Well welcome, hopefully you can become a vital member of the community and really help to push far ahead of google. Which Im sure the development team would love. This will of course earn you alot points too and get you on the leaders board. z d n e t t h a n k Im not sure i come to an agreement with you on every level, howevor it absolutely was a good posting, many thanks for taking the time to put up your ideas.
Thanks nice info z d n e t I really liked your current article write more..let me add you to its favorite
I really enjoyed reading this post !!!have bookmarked w e b s will come back to read more.
Fantastic news about the new release.I positively enjoying each little bit of it and I have you b o o k m a r k e d to check out new stuff you weblog post.Im not sure i come to an agreement with you on every level, howevor it absolutely was a good posting, many thanks for taking the time to put up your ideas
That's why i will never use FB - i don't trust those big companies out there. Do you know how they use your contact details - do they keep it private or share it? Can details leech by accident? For example i see news all over the net that some guy from Vimax lost his DVD with bunch of private details like SSNs and DLs
Good day to confirm this comment I would appreciate T h e b e s t o f Z D N e t d e l i v e r e d your website very nice to everyone Yes, Oracle is the only one with shared-disk architecture, but that is there advantage. It means you can add or remove nodes and the database lives on. In a shared nothing architecture, if you lose a node, you lose the system. I'm sure Oracle appreciates EMC highlighting their advantage.I also desire to signal in your RSS feeds. Thank you as soon as once again and maintain up the great operate Awesome post! Thank you very much || thanks for nice content this is really benefit to me.

Join the conversation!

Formatting +
BB Codes - Note: HTML is not supported in forums
  • [b] Bold [/b]
  • [i] Italic [/i]
  • [u] Underline [/u]
  • [s] Strikethrough [/s]
  • [q] "Quote" [/q]
  • [ol][*] 1. Ordered List [/ol]
  • [ul][*] · Unordered List [/ul]
  • [pre] Preformat [/pre]
  • [quote] "Blockquote" [/quote]
ie8 fix

The best of ZDNet, delivered

ZDNet Newsletters

Get the best of ZDNet delivered straight to your inbox

Facebook Activity

White Papers, Webcasts, & Resources
ie8 fix