/>
X
Innovation

All-in-one printers: efficient and useful, often unnecessary.

Katherine Boehret at WSJ.com has a breakdown of three all-in-one printers that starts off with a promising, "All-in-one machines that print, copy and scan are becoming much more compact and affordable, and most important, easier to use.
nusca-techonomy2013-640x465.jpg
Written by Andrew Nusca on

ZDNet Canon ImageClassKatherine Boehret at WSJ.com has a breakdown of three all-in-one printers that starts off with a promising, "All-in-one machines that print, copy and scan are becoming much more compact and affordable, and most important, easier to use."

And that may be true, indeed -- but are they any more worth it?

In her column, Boehret tested the performance of three all-in-ones that cost around $100: Eastman Kodak's new $130 ESP 3 All-in-One Printer, Canon's $100 PIXMA MP470 and Hewlett-Packard's $100 HP Photosmart C4280. All are "geared toward home users so they don't include the ability to fax, and they print great quality photos."

Yet every time I find myself using one of these machines, I feel left wanting more. It's kind of like Olive Garden's Sampler Italiano -- sometimes I'd like calamari, stuffed mushrooms and fried mozzarella all at once. But other times, I really just want a couple more stuffed mushrooms.

Eating references aside, I think all-in-ones are a great introductory product. But considering the price of ink these days, I feel my money is better spent buying just what I need -- which, in an office like mine, means a fast laser printer and a great scanner.

Sure, once in a blue moon I'd love to print out a photo at my own convenience -- but I'd rather not take the hit on pricey ink every day for that isolated need. And the fact that the three machines Boehret reviewed are all under $100 means that there's only so many resources to go around for the price.

On the other hand, I have plenty of friends that love their multifunction machines.

Tell me, readers: what do you think: are all-in-ones "all that" or "all crap"? Tell us in TalkBack. (In the meantime, here are some of ZDNet's most recently reviewed multipurpose printers -- including the Canon and HP listed above.)

Editorial standards

Related

How to use your phone to diagnose your car's 'check engine' light
BlueDriver Bluetooth dongle

How to use your phone to diagnose your car's 'check engine' light

Don't let Janet Jackson's 'Rhythm Nation' crash your old laptop
the-old-hard-disk-drive-is-disintegrating-in-space.jpg

Don't let Janet Jackson's 'Rhythm Nation' crash your old laptop

Google Play malware: If you've downloaded these malicious apps, delete them immediately
a-man-sitting-in-his-living-room-looking-at-his-smartphone-with-concern

Google Play malware: If you've downloaded these malicious apps, delete them immediately