Bill Gates, any regrets? Ctrl-Alt-Delete should be a single button

Bill Gates again blames IBM for creating the Ctrl-Alt-Del command instead of having one button do the job.
Written by Liam Tung, Contributing Writer

Bill Gates: "Sure, if I can make one small edit, I'd make that a single-key operation."

Image: Bloomberg

Microsoft co-founder Bill Gates says if he could go back in time, there'd be something more intuitive than the two-handed Ctrl-Alt-Delete command to interrupt a process.

Gates' made his latest remarks about the command at a Bloomberg business forum when asked by Carlyle Group's David Rubenstein why he chose Ctrl-Alt-Del for logging on to a Windows machine.

As he did some years ago, Gates pinned the blame on the IBM engineers responsible for the IBM PC keyboard at the time.

Grinning, he answered: "The IBM PC hardware keyboard only had one way that it could get a guaranteed interrupt generated. So, clearly the people involved, they should have put another key on it to make that work. A lot of machines these days do have that as a more obvious function."

Rubenstein pressed Gates further, asking whether he regretted doing it that way. Gates sidesteps the question but admits he might do things differently now.

"Well, I'm not sure you can go back in life and change small things in your life without putting other things at risk. Sure, if I can make one small edit, I'd make that a single-key operation."

In 2013 Gates said it was "mistake" requiring the three keys before logging in to Windows, and also blamed IBM engineers who "didn't wanna give us our single button".

The three-key function was created by IBM engineer David Bradley who intended for it to be shortcut to rebooting an IBM PC.

On a panel in 2011 with Gates, Bradley said, "I have to share the credit. I may have invented it, but Bill made it famous", by using it for the Windows NT logon.

As Ars Technica noted at the time, the function was initially a BIOS feature, but Microsoft made it software feature in Windows 3.0's Enhanced Mode.

Later, Microsoft hoped to sell Windows NT to the US government, which required a Secure Attention Key (SAK) that only the operating system could respond to. This stipulation was to prevent malware from spoofing a login prompt. Ctrl-Alt-Del became Windows' SAK.

Previous and related coverage

Bill Gates: 'Robots that take jobs should be taxed just like the people they replace'

Microsoft co-founder Bill Gates thinks governments should impose something akin to an income tax on each robot that replaces a human.

iPhone X expensive? No, $999 is a 'value price', says Apple CEO Tim Cook

Apple's new iPhone X $999 price tag only looks expensive, according to Apple chief Tim Cook.

More on Windows

Editorial standards