Why you can trust ZDNet ZDNet independently tests and researches products to bring you our best recommendations and advice. When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. Our process

'ZDNet Recommends': What exactly does it mean?

ZDNet's recommendations are based on many hours of testing, research, and comparison shopping. We gather data from the best available sources, including vendor and retailer listings as well as other relevant and independent reviews sites. And we pore over customer reviews to find out what matters to real people who already own and use the products and services we’re assessing.

When you click through from our site to a retailer and buy a product or service, we may earn affiliate commissions. This helps support our work, but does not affect what we cover or how, and it does not affect the price you pay. Neither ZDNet nor the author are compensated for these independent reviews. Indeed, we follow strict guidelines that ensure our editorial content is never influenced by advertisers.

ZDNet's editorial team writes on behalf of you, our reader. Our goal is to deliver the most accurate information and the most knowledgeable advice possible in order to help you make smarter buying decisions on tech gear and a wide array of products and services. Our editors thoroughly review and fact-check every article to ensure that our content meets the highest standards. If we have made an error or published misleading information, we will correct or clarify the article. If you see inaccuracies in our content, please report the mistake via this form.


The best fire extinguishers: Essential for your home and car

What is the best fire extinguisher? Our pick is the Buckeye 2.5lb fire extinguisher (4-pack). We analyzed quantity, contents, class, and refill-ability.
Written by Adrian Kingsley-Hughes, Contributor on

Over the past few years, people have been busy setting up home offices and home learning spaces. And what started out as something that seemed temporary has, for many, become a semi-permanent, or perhaps even a permanent, thing. Maybe you did what everyone else did and grabbed a free table and chair, an extension cord or two, and built a workspace.

But there's one bit of kit -- an essential, in my opinion -- that many have forgotten in the midst of all the hard work of setting up a work or learning space: A fire extinguisher.

Fires are, thankfully, quite rare. But they do happen, and throwing in extension cords and chargers and a bunch of electronics into a space can increase that chance. Sure, it's a small increase, but it's an increase all the same. 

A fire extinguisher can literally be a lifesaver.

While most electronic devices give you warnings before erupting into flames -- noxious fumes, arcing sounds, and even flashes -- things can erupt into an enthusiastic inferno without warning.

This is where having a fire extinguisher handy could mean the difference between life and death.

Tip: It's also a great idea to have a fire extinguisher in the car, but it needs to be quickly and easily accessible! Keeping it in the trunk under a bunch of stuff is pointless.

Buckeye 2.5lb fire extinguisher

Class: A, B, and C | Refillable: Yes | Contents: Dry powder | Quantity: 4 | 

A great solution for the home. 

The four-pack means there's enough to go around without breaking the bank. Each comes with a bracket to make wall mounting easy.


  •    Refillable 
  •    Easy to read gauge 
  •    Convenient four-pack 


  •    Rather bulky 
First Alert Pro5 carbon dioxide fire extinguisher

Class: A, B and C | Refillable: Yes | Contents: Carbon dioxide | Quantity: 1 |

Carbon dioxide fire extinguishers smother the fire in a gas rather than a dry powder, which means a lot less mess and clean up after the fact.  It also doesn't damage things that haven't already been damaged by the fire. 


  •    Doesn't leave a mess like dry powder does 
  •    Refillable and affordable
  •    Perfect for electrical fires 


  •    Not suitable for wood and paper fires 
  •    Mount is not the most secure
Kiddie FA110 multi-purpose fire extinguishers (3-pack)

Class: A, B, C, and K | Refillable: No | Contents: Foam | Quantity: 3 | 

Not the biggest or the most expensive, but an effective tool against small fires. Can also be used on a wider array of fires, making it great for the home, office, kitchen, and even the garage and car. 


  •    Small 
  •    Class K support, so great in the kitchen 
  •    Cheap


  •    Foam leaves a messy residue 
  •    No wall bracket 

What is the best fire extinguisher?

The best fire extinguisher is the Buckeye 2.5lb fire extinguisher (4-pack), because of its quantity, contents, class, and refill-ability. The 4-pack allows you to have a fire extinguisher in several rooms, and one in your car.

What kind of extinguisher do you need?

I mean, they all look much the same. Red cylinders fixed to brackets on the wall.

The main thing to look for when buying a fire extinguisher is the class of the extinguisher. For home environments, you're likely to be tackling burning paper, wood, and fabrics, electrical fires, gasoline or other liquid fuel fires, and oil fires (in the kitchen).

Fire extinguishers come in different classes. The classes applicable to home use are:

  • Class A - Wood, paper, cardboard, fabrics, plastics
  • Class B - Flammable liquids such gasoline and diesel
  • Class C - Electric and electrical fires
  • Class K - Cooking oil and grease

Should you get a big or small fire extinguisher?

It can be tempting to go for the biggest extinguisher you can find, but remember, you're very unlikely to be tackling a big fire (and don't get brave, leave that to the professionals). A home fire extinguisher is for small fires, to buy you time, or to help you get out. 

So, better to pick one that's not going to take up a huge about of room or going to end up buried under stuff or in a closet.

What's the difference between refillable and disposable fire extinguishers?

Some fire extinguishers can be refilled after use. These will also need periodic inspection and maintenance at specified intervals. Disposable fire extinguishers are one-use and have a fixed lifespan, after which they will need to be discarded.

Our process

In my experience with electrical fires and fire extinguishers, having a decent fire extinguisher gives you three things:

  • The ability to put out small fires
  • It buys you time to get out and call the fire department
  • It gives you a tool to help you get out if your exit is blocked by fire

The extinguishers selected above ticks these boxes and at the same time are also cost-effective (it's better to buy an extinguisher now, rather than to save up for a more expensive one in the future!).

Another factor is the ease of use. In the midst of a fire is not the time to be familiarizing yourself with how things work. Most extinguishers are easy to use -- point and shoot -- but it's a good idea to get up to speed on how your extinguishers work before you need them.

Also worth considering

A fire extinguisher is no good if you're not aware of the fire in the first place. This means that you need to fit smoke detectors as your first line of defense, and also, depending on how your property is heated, a carbon monoxide detector. Also, for grease fires in kitchens, a fire blanket may be more useful and make less mess than a fire extinguisher if a pan catches alight.


Best early Amazon Prime Day 2022 deals on Fire TV devices
Placeholder product image alt text

Best early Amazon Prime Day 2022 deals on Fire TV devices

Best silent mouse (2022)

Best silent mouse (2022)

Office Hardware & Appliances
7 best cybersecurity certifications of 2022

7 best cybersecurity certifications of 2022

Computers & Tech