HP Australia ordered to compensate customers for printer tech

Around 2,000 customers will be compensated AU$50 by HP Australia, after the company installed technology on its printers to prevent non-HP ink cartridges from being used without telling consumers.
Written by Corinne Reichert, Contributor

The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) has told HP PPS Australia to compensate customers who purchased its printers without being told they contained technology that did not allow for non-HP ink cartridges to be used in them.

The court-enforceable undertaking, given to the wholly owned subsidiary of HP, outlines how an "undisclosed technology" known as Dynamic Security Feature (DSF) was deployed to prevent anything other than HP-branded ink cartridges from being used in around 220,000 printers in Australia.

DSF was either installed prior to purchase or installed thereafter through firmware updates downloaded by users, with many customers receiving error messages in September 2016 that non-HP ink cartridges were damaged and could not be installed -- or simply having their non-HP cartridges rejected by the printer.

HP has admitted to likely breaching Australian Consumer Law by engaging in false, misleading, or deceptive conduct by not disclosing that the printers used DSF technology preventing other brands of ink cartridges from being used.

"Consumers were not made aware of the restriction on using non-HP ink cartridges when buying the printer or downloading the firmware update, and were denied the choice to accept or reject it," ACCC Deputy Chair Dr Michael Schaper said on Tuesday.

"The ACCC was also very concerned that HP used technology to change these printers' functionality after purchase, without alerting consumers to the restriction on the use of non-HP ink cartridges, which was being installed."

According to the ACCC, around 2,000 customers were affected, with each to be compensated AU$50 by HP -- totalling an approximate AU$100,000 compensation bill.

The company is also required to "make clear on its packaging and at point of sale" if DSF technology has been used on a printer and what its effects are, and it has since made an automatic firmware update available to remove DSF tech from some of its printers.

The 10 HP inkjet printer models affected by DSF tech during that time were the HP OfficeJet Pro 6230, HP OfficeJet 6820, HP OfficeJet Pro 6830, HP OfficeJet Pro 8610, HP OfficeJet Pro 8620, HP OfficeJet Pro 8630, HP OfficeJet Pro X551dw, HP OfficeJet Pro X476dw MFP, HP OfficeJet Pro X576dw MFP, and HP OfficeJet Pro X451dw.

HP Australia also found itself in the ACCC's crosshairs back in 2012, when the consumer watchdog launched proceedings in the Australian Federal Court alleging false or misleading representations to consumers on warranties and replacements.

The company admitted to breaching Australian Consumer Law in 2013 during those court proceedings, but argued that there was "no evidence to establish the extent of the damage done to consumers and on how many people were affected by it".

However, it ended up paying AU$3 million in civil pecuniary penalties as a result.

HP Australia was also forced to change its claims and complaints processing and handling procedures back in 2009 after the ACCC received multiple complaints about cash-back and gift promotions.

Related Coverage

Valve dismissal by Australian High Court ends 4-year legal battle against ACCC

Valve's attempt to appeal a AU$3 million penalty and ruling that it engaged in deceptive conduct has been dismissed by the High Court of Australia.

ACCC puts question mark over MYOB's Reckon Accountants Group acquisition

The watchdog is concerned MYOB would likely be the only supplier of practice software suitable for medium and large accounting firms if the proposed AU$180 million acquisition of Reckon's Accountants Group proceeds.

ACCC slaps Activ8me for claiming endorsement by consumer watchdog

NBN satellite broadband retailer claimed the endorsement of ACCC because it topped satellite customer numbers.

Netgear hit by ACCC for likely misleading Australians

Yet another American company is caught out telling fibs about Australian law.

HP's new Multi Jet printer series will 3D-print fully functional, colour parts

HP is aiming to democratise additive manufacturing with a fast prototyping system that runs on the same platform and materials as its production-ready 3D printers.

HP's $50K 3D printer shows voxels, open materials will drive future manufacturing (TechRepublic)

The new HP Jet Fusion 300/500 Series aims to make better functional prototypes and democratize 3D printing.

Mobile device computing policy (Tech Pro Research)

Mobile devices offer convenience and flexibility for the modern workforce - but they also bring associated risks and support issues. This policy establishes guidelines to help ensure safe and productive mobility.

Editorial standards