/>
X

When products begin to falter, pursue patents

Patent inventions, or ideas? When it comes to software, the line is fuzzy -- and the system is broken either way, Google patent counsel Tim Porter says.
nusca-techonomy2013-640x465.jpg
Written by Andrew Nusca, Former editor on

Patents: for inventions, or merely ideas?

The San Francisco Chronicle published on Sunday a fascinating interview with Google's patent counsel, Tim Porter, who argues that the system itself is broken and that Microsoft -- sometime partner, sometime bitter rival -- pursues patent litigation when its own products "stop succeeding in the marketplace."

"The concern is that the more people get distracted with litigation, the less they'll be inventing," Porter said to columnist James Temple.

Five things I learned from the Q&A:

  1. "Innovation happens without patents." In other words, deregulation helps.
  2. A large part of the current mobile court scrum is due to "a 10- or 15-year period when the issuance of software patents was too lax."
  3. "You shouldn't patent something that's obvious." The question, of course, is what's obvious to whom.
  4. Huge damages awards are fueling patent lawsuits. Bring these more into scale with the complaint and reduce the backlog of frivolous claims.
  5. This environment has pressured companies like Google to spend enormous sums of money to purchase patent portfolios for legal defense.

As a side note, Ars Technica's Tim Lee goes deeper into the issue, examining the levers that could (or couldn't) make litigation less appealing. His conclusion? Google is part of the problem, because it's spending too much time buying into the system instead of reforming it.

What say you, developers?

Google lawyer: Why the patent system is broken [SF Chronicle]

Related

Delta Air Lines just made an embarrassing announcement (you may be livid)
screen-shot-2022-06-22-at-3-50-54-pm.png

Delta Air Lines just made an embarrassing announcement (you may be livid)

Business
US weather, climate forecasting is about to get way better
screen-shot-2017-09-07-at-1.jpg

US weather, climate forecasting is about to get way better

Innovation
Cybersecurity leaders are anticipating mass resignations within the year - here's why
cybersecurity

Cybersecurity leaders are anticipating mass resignations within the year - here's why

Security