Tier two telcos AAPT and Primus have
indicated they have no immediate intention to follow Optus and
sue Telstra over the heavyweight's December increase in one of its
wholesale line rental plans.
Optus announced yesterday it would sue Telstra in the Federal
Court for damages in the range of tens of millions of dollars for
the price increase.
The legal action will come on the back of a formal notice
issued by the nation's competition regulator the Australian
Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) last week claiming Telstra's
December move was uncompetitive.
But while Optus has reacted immediately to the so-called "Part
A competition notice", two of the telcos most affected by the
price rise, Primus and AAPT, indicated they wouldn't move just
"The position hasn't been finalised. [Legal action] is
something that we are examining but no decision has been made on
whether to take legal action at this point," a spokesperson for
Primus told ZDNet Australia via e-mail.
"AAPT is still pursuing the matter through its own dispute
settlement procedures with Telstra," AAPT's head of regulatory
affairs David Havyatt said by e-mail.
"We are hoping the competition notice will make Telstra see
sense before there is any need for us to take the same action as
While primarily broadband-focused telco iiNet only had around
71,000 phone services when Telstra increased prices last year,
the company has also been vocal on the issue. However iiNet is similarly unlikely to immediately pursue legal
iiNet's general manager of regulatory affairs Steve Dalby told
ZDNet Australia in a telephone interview late last week his
company was cooperating with the ACCC on the issue.
"We've been involved with discussions with the ACCC since
around around Christmas I guess, when Telstra made that change to
its pricing structure," he said. "We'll continue to help them
with their enquiries."
The ACCC's competition notice had forestalled independent
legal action under the Trade Practices Act by iiNet and others,
"When the ACCC didn't seem to be taking any action on it, we
discussed it with some other members of the industry and we'd
started the process going to take our own private case to court
to challenge Telstra using the Trade Practices Act," he said.
"Fortunately the ACCC since then has taken up the cudgel and
so that private action is on hold."
A Telstra spokeswoman reiterated the company's stance that its prices were "completely fair and justified" and that Optus' price comparisons were misleading.