Why you can trust ZDNet
Our recommendations are based on many hours of testing, research, and comparison shopping. We may earn a commission when you purchase a product through our links. This helps support our work but does not influence what we write about or the price you pay. Our editors thoroughly review and fact check every article. Our process

‘ZDNet Recommends’: What exactly does that mean?

ZDNet’s recommendations are based on many hours of testing, research, and comparison shopping. We gather data from the best available sources, including vendor and retailer listings as well as other relevant and independent reviews sites. And we pore over customer reviews to find out what matters to real people who already own and use the products and services we’re assessing.

When you click through from our site to a retailer and buy a product or service, we may earn affiliate commissions. This helps support our work, but does not affect what we cover or how, and it does not affect the price you pay. Neither ZDNet nor the author are compensated for these independent reviews. Indeed, we follow strict guidelines that ensure our editorial content is never influenced by advertisers.

ZDNet's editorial team writes on behalf of you, our reader. Our goal is to deliver the most accurate information and the most knowledgeable advice possible in order to help you make smarter buying decisions on tech gear and a wide array of products and services. Our editors thoroughly review and fact-check every article to ensure that our content meets the highest standards. If we have made an error or published misleading information, we will correct or clarify the article. If you see inaccuracies in our content, please report the mistake via this form.

Close

The best smart speakers: Should you go with Alexa, Siri, or Google Assistant?

What is the best smart speaker? Our recommendation is the Echo Dot. ZDNet looked at the best smart speakers available on the market today to come up with our top five picks.

Gone are the days of having simple speakers that pump your favorite tunes throughout your home. It's clear that smart speakers are the future. That is, speakers you can talk to and interact with, asking random questions, getting weather updates or controlling your smart home devices are only part of what makes them so attractive. 

The speakers available today have evolved over the years, and instead of coming in basic designs and one size, there's now a wide offering of speakers that interact with Amazon's Alexa, Google Assistant, or Apple's Siri. Honestly, if you're looking to buy one, it can quickly get confusing trying to figure out which is the best for you. 

So, to help you properly outfit your office with premium sound and voice control, ZDNet has rounded up five smart speakers that satisfy a range of wants and needs. Instead of getting off into the weeds of third-party designs, we tried to stick with devices straight from Apple, Google, and Amazon themselves. That doesn't mean we don't like third-party designs -- in fact, we included one below -- but buying first-party ensures long-term support, software updates, and compatibility. 

Amazon Echo Dot (4th Gen)

Best overall option

Amazon Echo Dot (4th Gen)
Image: Amazon

Amazon arguably started the entire smart speaker trend with its Echo lineup, and with the 4th generation Echo Dot continues to move the lineup's design, and your conversations with Alexa, forward. The orb-like design has a cloth fabric covering that comes in multiple color options, and if you're comfortable with putting a speaker in a child's bedroom, you can get a Kids Edition that features an animal pattern. 

There's a light-up ring around the bottom of the Echo Dot that lets you know when Alexa is listening, or when the microphone is turned off. There are button controls on top of the speaker that let you adjust volume or turn off the mic with a quick tap. 

At $34.99, it's one of the least expensive options you'll find for a smart speaker, and it doesn't give up any features. You'll still be able to use Alexa to control your smart home, ask for jokes or place calls. 

Also: Best Amazon Echo: Which Alexa device is right for you?

Pros:

  • Amazon's smarthome ecosystem is strong 
  • Fun design 
  • Affordable

Cons:

  • Sound quality is just okay

Nest Audio

Best option from Google

Nest Audio
Google

Remember when all smart speakers looked the same? Thankfully that's changing, and Nest Audio is a prime example of that. For $99, you get a pillow-like speaker that works with Google Assistant, allowing you to control your smart devices, ask questions, and stream music. 

There's a built-in mic switch that disables the mic altogether for those who are privacy-conscious. It also has three far-field microphones, a 75mm woofer and a 19mm tweeter. 

Nest Audio comes in five different color options. 

Pros:

  • Unique design looks great
  • Google Assistant smart home ecosystem
  • Good sound quality

Cons:

  • Finicky touch controls

Apple HomePod Mini

Best compact option

Apple HomePod Mini
Image: Apple

Apple released the HomePod Mini towards the end of 2020, adding a speaker with a more compact design and a lower price than the original, and now discontinued, HomePod. Near the end of 2021, Apple released three new color options for the HomePod Mini, bringing the total color options to five.  

The $99 HomePod Mini doesn't have the same sound quality you'll get from its bigger sibling. However, it's more than powerful enough to fill a room. It still boasts the ability to hear you from across the room, even when it's blasting your favorite tunes. 

It includes an ultra-wideband chip that works with the iPhone 11 or newer, making the process for handing off music between your phone and the Mini -- or vice-versa -- a breeze. Plus, it doubles as a HomeKit hub with Thread support, allowing compatible accessories to stay connected at all times. 

Pros:

  • Tight Apple ecosystem integration
  • Affordable
  • Thread support

Cons:

  • Tight Apple ecosystem integration
  • Decent sound quality 

Amazon Echo Studio

Best top-of-the-line option

Amazon Echo Studio

Amazon's largest Echo speaker is called the Echo Studio. It's a high-end choice with high-fidelity sound and an equally high-end price. But, for $200, you're getting 3D audio with a five-speaker setup and Dolby Atmos support. You can even pair the Studio with a second unit to create a home theater-like setup. 

There's all the native Alexa functionality you can expect from an Amazon device, too. 

Pros:

  • Amazon's smarthome ecosystem is strong 
  • Amazing sound quality 
  • Can be paired for stereo sound

Cons:

  • Expensive
  • Very big

Sonos Move

Best portable option

Sonos Move

The Sonos Move has built-in Alexa, Google Assistant and doubles as an AirPlay 2 or Bluetooth compatible speaker. But what really makes the Move stand out is that it has a rechargeable battery with 11 hours of life, making it a great choice if you plan on moving in and out of or around the office pretty regularly. It also has a weather-proof body in case you get caught out in the rain or bring it to the beach on holiday. 

Pros:

  • Integrates with all smarthome platforms
  • Portable
  • Battery life

Cons:

  • Big and heavy for a portable speaker
  • Pricey

Which is the best smart speaker?

Our pick is the Echo Dot, but here's your decision tree

If you don't currently have any sort of smart speaker in your home, then I suggest by starting your search based on the type of smartphone you carry. If you have an iPhone, then Apple's HomePod Mini makes sense. You'll be able to send messages, listen to Apple Music and control your HomeKit accessories through the small speaker. 

If you have an Android phone, then Nest Audio might be a better fit for you since it tightly integrates with the Google Home app and all of the supported smart home platforms. 

However, Amazon's Alexa offers support for a vast list of products, services and smart home devices. It's a reliable solution for those who maybe have a split household, with some using an iPhone and others using an Android device. 

Finally, if you want something that supports all platforms and allows you to switch between them at will? Sonos Move will do just that. 

Smart Speaker

Echo Dot

Nest Audio

HomePod Mini

Echo Studio

Sonos Move

Price

$49

$99

$99

$199

$399

Smart home support

Alexa

Google Assistant

HomeKit

Alexa

Alexa, Google Assistant, AirPlay 2

Bluetooth support

Yes

Yes

No

Yes

Yes

Colors

Twilight blue, charcoal, glacier, white

Chalk, charcoal, sage, sand, sky

White, yellow, orange, blue, space gray

Black

Black and white

How did we select these smart speakers?

It's a fair question. I've personally used and extensively tested every speaker on this list, giving me firsthand knowledge about performance, build quality and the overall experience. When it comes to Google and Amazon smart speakers, both companies allow third parties to build speakers that integrate with the respective voice assistant -- I purposely left most of those speakers off of this list. 

Oftentimes, those speakers lack any long-term support via software updates. The only exception is Sonos, who has a reliable track record with supporting hardware and software for many years. 

Are there alternative smart speakers worth considering?

Here are a few other options to look into:

Show Comments