I paid $820 for an iPhone 5 to keep unlimited LTE data on Verizon

There are many of us that are not eligible for the full $450 subsidy on the iPhone 5. Tradeoffs and decisions have to be made to choose the right carrier and phone for you and I am excited to get my Verizon iPhone 5.

I paid $820 for an iPhone 5 to keep unlimited LTE data on Verizon

Yesterday I wrote that the iPhone 5 announcement was a bit underwhelming  primarily because everything leaked out beforehand and there was no big surprise at the event. I acknowledged that the iPhone 5 looked to be a great device and would sell millions and I wasn't saying the iPhone 5 was junk or anything. After some more consideration, and since it is my job to check out the latest devices and provide my opinions, I decided to proceed with purchasing an iPhone 5 for myself.

Unlike other smartphone makers, Apple only loans out a few iPhones to select sites and thus if I want to check one out I have to purchase it for myself. While the discussion below pertains to me and my situation of currently having three carrier contracts, I thought some of the factors going into my decisions might help some of you as you try to figure out a game plan for the iPhone 5.

Do I buy a Verizon iPhone 5?

I have a grandfathered Verizon unlimited data plan and currently use either a Galaxy Nexus or my new iPad with the SIM. My first thought was to just buy an iPhone 5 at full price and then pop that SIM (with an adapter) into other devices and my iPad. I pay $85 per month for 450 minutes, unlimited data, and 250 text messages. The full unsubsidized price of the 32GB iPhone 5 I want (16GB just doesn't provide enough room to test apps and since I don't carry that much music then 64GB seems like overkill) is $749, plus nearly 10% tax in Washington. I could buy full price and keep my unlimited data or pay about $200 remaining on my contract in ETF and then pay $299 for the subsidized 32GB model. I could save $250 going this route, but would lose my unlimited data and then be forced into a monthly shared plan with their shared data for about $30 more per month. Thus, over a 24 month period I would end up paying a LOT more by accepting the subsidy.

Verizon is fantastic for rural areas of Washington and LTE is extensive near the cities where I work and play. I have been thinking about paying the ETF and dropping Verizon since their Windows Phone support has been minimal, but I get amazingly fast LTE and unlimited data is pretty compelling for a smartphone geek.

Or do I buy an AT&T iPhone 5?

I have a fairly new AT&T account I started when I bought the Nokia Lumia 900 and an ETF at this time would be about $300. The full price of the iPhone 5 is $749, plus tax, while the subsidy price of a 32GB model is $299. Thus I could buy at full price and keep my existing account and carry over minutes or I could pay the ETF and buy a subsidized phone with a new account. The savings of paying the ETF and starting a new account is about $150, but it is also a bit of a hassle to end a contact and deal with final bills. I have no grandfathered bonuses on AT&T and don't care about losing rollover minutes.

As you know I also buy and use smartphones running other operating systems and AT&T is the premier Windows Phone partner so I will likely be able to get a Nokia Lumia 920 when they come out in a couple months. There is also the possibility that T-Mobile's network rollout will let me use the iPhone 5 with my T-Mobile SIM over 3G in the near future. I get a good AT&T signal, but no LTE yet, so I won't see the super fast LTE speeds. AT&T also charges another $20 per month for text messages so the monthly fee is quite high.

Which one did I preorder?

There was talk online that you wouldn't be able to buy these devices at full price without a contract and when I walked through the Verizon site that looked like it might be the case since they tried to get me to select a plan. I went through the Apple site and my receipt clearly shows my unlimited data, 450 minutes, and 250 text messages remain intact. Thus, I ended up paying $820.16 for my iPhone 5 on Verizon and will be posting thoughts when it arrives next Friday.

BTW, another reason I went with the Verizon iPhone 5 is that it was pretty easy to unlock it and use it overseas while AT&T has never been friendly at unlocking iPhones in the past.


You have been successfully signed up. To sign up for more newsletters or to manage your account, visit the Newsletter Subscription Center.
See All
See All