iPhone battery row: Apple target of new probe that also focuses on Samsung

Apple faces yet another investigation by European regulators over iPhone battery slowdowns.
Written by Liam Tung, Contributing Writer

Video: How to check if your iPhone battery needs to be replaced

Italy's antitrust authority has opened an investigation into claims that Apple and Samsung have used software updates to hobble phones and encourage consumers to upgrade hardware.

It's the latest sign of trouble for Apple over the power-management feature it introduced in iOS 10.2 and again in iOS 11 to counter unexpected shutdowns on iPhones with aged batteries.

In January, French prosecutors opened a probe over the battery-slowdown controversy, which is now being handled by France's competition and consumer protection authority, the DGCCRF.

Reuters reports that Apple and Samsung face multimillion euro fines if they're found guilty of infringing four separate articles of Italy's consumers' code.

The Italian authority said the two smartphone makers are suspected of engaging in "a general commercial policy taking advantage of the lack of certain components to curb the performance times of their products and induce consumers to buy new versions".

In a statement, the watchdog said the two companies pushed software updates to phones "without reporting the possible consequences" of the update and without information to maintain the performance they were promoted as having when they were sold.


Apple CEO Tim Cook: "Maybe we should have been clearer at a point in time but our actions were always the purest."

Image: ABC News/YouTube

Late last year, Apple admitted the existence of an iOS power management feature after a Geekbench test found a connection between iPhone performance and battery age while investigating a post from a Reddit user, who had found that an iPhone became faster after replacing the battery.

Apple now faces dozens of class action lawsuits in the US for degrading the performance of iPhones. The number of lawsuits has swelled from 32 a fortnight ago to 45 in the US today, according to Patently Apple.

To appease angry consumers, Apple announced it would replace iPhone batteries for $29 instead of the usual $79. The class actions have piled up despite Apple's attempt to placate the public.

Download now: IT hardware procurement policy

Now a South Korean consumer group has filed a criminal complaint against Apple CEO Tim Cook over the issue, Reuters reported today. The Citizens United for Consumer Sovereignty accused Apple of destruction of property and fraud.

Apple is also planning a software update that will provide more transparency about the condition of an iPhone's battery, and will let consumers switch off the performance management feature -- even if it leads to more unexpected shutdowns.

Cook explained the feature in an interview with ABC World News Tonight yesterday.

"We will tell somebody we are reducing the performance by some amount in order not to have an unexpected restart and if you don't want it, you can turn it off," he said.

"Now, we don't recommend it because we think that people's iPhones are really important to them, and you never can tell when something is so urgent and so, our actions were all in service of the user... Maybe we should have been clearer at a point in time but our actions were always the purest."

Previous and related coverage

iPhone throttling: Class actions pile up as Apple hit with 32nd lawsuit

More lawsuits land at Apple's feet over its decision to slow down iPhones with older batteries.

Tim Cook: 'Maybe we should have been clearer' over iPhone throttling

In a recent interview, Apple CEO Tim Cook acknowledged the company should have been clearer with iPhone owners.

Can Apple dig itself out of the 'iPhone throttling' hole it created for itself?

Apple's response to being caught throttling older iPhones has been shockingly bad.

Cook: Apple will release software update to fix iPhone battery slowdown issue (TechRepublic)

Users will be able to opt out of the feature that slows iPhones when the battery is low.

iPhone battery replacement: Here are the best options (CNET)

You'll get more life out of your iPhone and maybe a performance boost to boot. Find out the costs, pros and cons of hiring a pro or doing it yourself.

Editorial standards