​Labor seeks updated My Health Record legislation to prevent privatisation

Australia's federal opposition party wants guarantees that My Health Record will never be privatised or commercialised, and that health data will be kept far away from private health insurers.
Written by Asha Barbaschow, Contributor

The federal opposition wants to fix the Australian government's controversial My Health Record, focusing in particular on amending legislation to ensure control of the online medical file can never be privatised or commercialised.

Labor has touted its plan as protecting the privacy of employees and women fleeing domestic violence, and as one protecting the public from having their medical history used by the likes of health insurers.

"Labor supports electronic health records. But the Senate inquiry we initiated into the My Health Record has exposed a range of deficiencies that must be addressed before this scheme rolls out to every Australian," a statement from Shadow Minister for Health and Medicare Catherine King said.

Specifically, Labor intends to move amendments to the Bill to prevent My Health Record from being privatised or commercialised; to disallow the Australian Digital Health Agency (ADHA) from ever delegating access to My Health Record to other entities; to ensure private health insurers cannot access the system's records, including de-identified data; that the privacy of employees is protected in the context of employer-directed healthcare; and that vulnerable children and parents such as those fleeing domestic violence are protected by narrowing the definition of parental responsibility.

King said the inquiry Labor announced in August revealed a range of "serious flaws" in the current legislation, which she believes were created by the government's rushed implementation of an opt-out model.

The federal government automatically signed Australians up to My Health Record, giving individuals who wished to opt out of the service from July 16 through to November 15, 2018, to do so.

As of September 12, around 900,000 Australians had opted out.

At the end of August, the government finally began addressing some of the legislative problems with My Health Record: Overly broad access for law enforcement, and the retention of data even when a health record is cancelled. This followed weeks of assertions by Health Minister Greg Hunt that such changes were unnecessary.

"While Labor supports the government's moves to tighten law enforcement access provisions and enable permanent record deletion, it's clear these measures alone are simply not enough," King's statement continued.

Speaking with ZDNet earlier this week, lawyer and writer Mike Godwin -- one of America's most prominent commentators on digital policy -- said that the benefits of My Health Record were unclear.

Godwin thinks the government has done "a very poor job" of justifying My Health Record. In the last couple of months of the opt-out window, at least, it's been trying to "propagandise" for the centralised digital health record system.

"Honestly, from my perspective, even the best-case stories of My Health Record are kind of lame," he said.

"If everybody had to carry around a shopping cart full of their health records for every visit to the doctor then you might have a case, but that doesn't seem to be a problem for most Australians."

Labor wants the opt-out of My Health Record to be suspended until its concerns are addressed.


Privacy advocates have failed to engage on My Health Record

Many of the concerns about Australia's centralised digital health records are real, but the abstract, hand-wavey arguments aren't persuading people outside the digital privacy bubble.

My Health Record access controls used only 214 times in million record trial

Individual document controls were used only 10 times during the electronic health record trial.

My Health Record woes detailed in leaked document: Report

It's time for the Australian Digital Health Agency to take a strategic approach, but it seems it would rather fix problems 'on the fly' or just ignore them.

Australian government moves to improve My Health Record privacy

It's hardly an example of legislative clarity, but the proposed amendments are intended to address key privacy concerns around the disclosure of personal medical information.

Why Australia is quickly developing a technology-based human rights problem (TechRepublic)

Human rights advocates have called on the Australian government to protect the rights of all in an era of change, saying tech should serve humanity, not exclude the most vulnerable members of society.

Editorial standards