'ZDNET Recommends': What exactly does it mean?
ZDNET's recommendations are based on many hours of testing, research, and comparison shopping. We gather data from the best available sources, including vendor and retailer listings as well as other relevant and independent reviews sites. And we pore over customer reviews to find out what matters to real people who already own and use the products and services we’re assessing.
When you click through from our site to a retailer and buy a product or service, we may earn affiliate commissions. This helps support our work, but does not affect what we cover or how, and it does not affect the price you pay. Neither ZDNET nor the author are compensated for these independent reviews. Indeed, we follow strict guidelines that ensure our editorial content is never influenced by advertisers.
ZDNET's editorial team writes on behalf of you, our reader. Our goal is to deliver the most accurate information and the most knowledgeable advice possible in order to help you make smarter buying decisions on tech gear and a wide array of products and services. Our editors thoroughly review and fact-check every article to ensure that our content meets the highest standards. If we have made an error or published misleading information, we will correct or clarify the article. If you see inaccuracies in our content, please report the mistake via this form.
The best fitness trackers to replace the Halo Band
Fitness trackers have taken the world by storm, and it's easy to see why. In addition to tracking exercise, you get daily insight into your health so you can level up your overall wellness.
If you're interested in tracking activity, receiving wellness insights, improving sleep habits, or just want a more accurate pedometer than your smartphone, there are plenty of fitness trackers on the market -- even with Amazon's abrupt discontinuation of its 'Halo' line.
While the variety of features, aesthetics, and approaches to fitness tracking are vast, it can often seem overwhelming -- especially when each one claims it's the most accurate, unobtrusive, etc. Those factors are important, yes, but like exercise, a wearable is something to serve your specific body, needs, and habits. That said, this list features fitness trackers of different approaches to form factors, tracking metrics, and wellness in general for you to compare and decide which fitness tracker is the best fit.
Also: The best smart rings that are reliable
- GPS
- Elegant, simple form factor
- Comfortable wear
- Daily readiness scores set a good benchmark
- Impressive battery life
- GPS performance can be inconsistent
- Fitbit Premium requires a monthly fee
- Workout data isn't the most detailed
Fitbit Charge 5 Specs: Display: 21.93 x 14.75mm; AMOLED color touchscreen with 326 ppi | Battery life: Up to seven days, five days when using continuous GPS | Dimensions: 36.7 x 22.7 x 11.2mm (sensor unit, not including band length) | Weight: 28 g | Water/dust resistance: Up to 50 meters, sweat, rain, and splash-proof | Connectivity: Bluetooth 4.0, GPS, NFC | Sleep tracking: Yes
Fitbit has long been known as one of the leading brands for fitness trackers, so it is no surprise that it leads the pack as the best fitness tracker you can buy. Along with calorie tracking, the Charge 5 calculates Sp02, skin temperature variation, and heart rate variability (HRV).
The Fitbit Charge 5's modern form factor is almost as impressive as its functionality with a display that's still versatile despite being a little over one inch wide. This is fantastic if you want a sleek, comfortable screen that doesn't engulf your entire wrist.
"The display is small but feels large for a tracker with extremely crisp fonts and brilliant colors. It lies fairly flat against your wrist and the touchscreen is very responsive," said longtime ZDNET contributor Matt Miller in his Charge 5 review.
Review: Fitbit Charge 5: Best fitness tracker with color display, GPS, and elegant form factor
If you're directionally challenged or just want to track your running route, another standout feature of the Charge 5 is a GPS map. In Miller's experience, the GPS feature "did an excellent job with walks, but [had] a couple of inconsistent experiences on runs."
Built into the Fitbit ecosystem, you'll also get access to a suite of meditations, workout videos, and a "daily readiness score." However, after a six-month trial, you'll be required to pay a fee to access Fitbit premium features. For other Fitbit options, make sure to check out our list of the best Fitbits.
- Week-long battery life
- Fashionable, discrete design
- Accurate sleep tracking
- Membership required
- Still chunkier than a normal ring
- Most feedback isn't immediate
- Have to get the ring sized
Oura Ring 3 specs: Materials: Titanium with PVD coating | Battery life: Four to seven days, full charge in 20-80 minutes |Dimensions: 7.9 by 2.5mm | Weight: 4-6 g, depending on size | Water/dust resistance: Waterproof and sweatproof | Connectivity: Bluetooth LE | Sleep Tracking: Yes
Don't like the bulky design or constant notifications that come with wearing a smartwatch, but want wellness insights? Enter the Oura Ring. Taking up a fraction of the real estate, the Oura Ring tracks exercise, sleep, and more. While a bit thick, the high-quality titanium ring with PVD coating looks and feels more like an everyday accessory than a fitness tracker.
ZDNET's Sherin Shibu recently purchased the ring for herself and was impressed by its minimalist and comfortable design along with its detailed and actionable insights, all without implementing a screen.
The ring is even subtle and sleek enough to wear at night. In fact, you're supposed to. Equipped with Sp02 sensors, the Oura Ring tracks heart rate variability (HRV) along with overall blood saturation levels during the night.
Much like its design, the Oura ring takes a more well-rounded approach to fitness rather than giving immediate stats. Using an intuitive app interface, you can access data on your own time, getting insight into data beyond activity tracked and calories burned. This insight includes recovery and readiness, and it is quite comprehensive.
"I think of the Oura as what happens overnight. It's more of a big level view of myself and my wellness, taking a step out and considering the consequences of what you've been doing for the past few weeks/days," said Dr. Jason Fanning, an assistant professor at Wake Forest University who researches the use of commercial and research-grade activity monitors.
Review: Is the Oura Ring 3 worth buying in 2023? Yes, if you value these features
"If I'm training too hard or too little, getting sick, if I've had too much alcohol -- all those things show up and give an idea on how I'll be feeling," Fanning elaborated.
The Oura Ring also features bedtime guidance, period prediction, and an "automatic nap" prompt. The only downside? In addition to the $299 price tag and custom fitting process, you'll need a membership fee to access the full suite of features. Non-paying members only have access to sleep, readiness, and activity.
- Enhanced sleep tracking features
- Crash detection notifies first responders
- Advanced workout metrics
- Less than 2-day battery life
- Sensors aren't a match for Samsung watches
Apple Watch Series 8 Specs: Display: 396 x 484 pixels OLED | Battery life: 18 hours | Dimensions: 45 x 30 x 10.7mm | Weight: 38.8 g | Water/dust resistance: 50m with IP6X | Connectivity: LTE cellular option, Wi-Fi, Bluetooth 5.0
Apple was an early adopter of the fitness-tracking trend, and the Apple Watch lineup continues to improve. I know, I know, it is a smartwatch, but with the right band, it can be more of a subtle statement than a techy eyesore. Plus, with upgraded battery life, top-quality performance, and a pretty accurate HRV, it's worth the consideration.
I reviewed the Apple Watch Series 8 in October and was quickly impressed with the quick charge time despite having a shorter battery life than competitors. The more advanced workout features, like showing your mile split and debuting a multi-sport function, also make the Series 8 a standout tracker. And, along with tracking your stride the Series 8 also made strides in women's health and sleep tracking features.
Review: Apple Watch 8 is a sleeper hit, even if it doesn't match Samsung's sensors
I found the sleep tracking stats to be extremely insightful, and the bedtime feature got me on a much-needed post-grad sleep schedule. While sleeping with a watch took some getting used to, I'm now conditioned to wake up from it buzzing on my wrist.
If you're an Apple user, this fitness tracker will work seamlessly with your device ecosystem and introduce new healthy habits aside from the typical workout tracking it's known for.
- Reliable health and fitness tracking
- Stylish design
- Wireless Qi charging
- Impressive battery life
- No physical knob or dial makes browsing difficult
- Often requires a wake-up tap to register input
Garmin Vívomove Trend specs: Display: 240 x 240 pixels, AMOLED | Battery life: Up to five days | Dimensions: 42 x 42 x 11.9mm | Weight: 42 g with silicone strap | Water/dust resistance: 5 ATM | Connectivity: Bluetooth and ANT+
If you prefer a timepiece with a timeless look, the Garmin Vívomove Trend is the perfect work-to-workout watch. Upon first glance, you might not notice that Garmin's latest hybrid watch is equipped with workout modes, oxygen monitoring, heart rate tracking, sleep tracking, and step counting capabilities.
The Garmin Vívomove Trend marries a traditional analog watch design -- motorized hands and all -- with a one-inch touchscreen display.
ZDNET Technology Editor June Wan tested the Vívomove Trend, and while he didn't put the watch through a tough mudder, he commended the watch's unique approach to tracking.
"It's a clever, fun scoring system that's calculated based on your sleep data, stress levels, physical activity, and more, to suggest when your body is capable of exerting more energy and when you should take a back seat," he said.
Review: Garmin's new Vívomove Trend fixes my biggest issue with its smartwatches
Aside from performance and aesthetics, the Vívomove Trend also packs an impressive battery life. During testing, Wan averaged about four days of use per charge. Along with ditching the massive display screen, you can also say goodbye to yet another charging cable, because the Vívomove Trend totes wireless charging.
- Comfortable for 24/7 wear
- Detailed sleep tracking
- Personalized data and coaching
- Portable block makes for a convenient charge
- Monthly subscription fee
- Tracking is heavily focused on recovery
- Can't manually import GPS data
Whoop 4.0 specs: Display: None | Battery life: 3-5 days | Dimensions: 1.7 x 1.1 x 0.4 inches | Weight: 2.8 g | Water/dust resistance: Up to 10 meters | Connectivity: Bluetooth
According to an article from Johns Hopkins, sleep trackers can be a useful tool for identifying sleep patterns. However, sleeping with a bulky screen on your wrist can potentially have the opposite effect. The Whoop 4.0 is a screen-less band that calculates your sleep performance by measuring the sleep you got versus the sleep your body needs.
Review: Whoop 4.0: Screenless wearable helps you avoid injuries, track sleep details
Given the detailed bodily insights, it makes sense why Whoop wearables are so popular among athletes. Former University of Notre Dame softball athlete Quinn Biggio started using the Whoop after hanging up her cleats for good and witnessing it successfully keeping her teammates in tune with their bodies.
"No longer was anyone telling me to wake up at 6:00 a.m. and go run or lift. I became fully in charge of my own workouts and schedule," she said.
The Whoop employs a nuanced sleep-tracking approach to how it tracks exercise. Rather than simply displaying workout stats, the Whoop calculates what it calls "strain" on its proprietary 0 to 21 scale. Strain accounts for exercise as well as lifestyle factors that make up our overall health: work, anxiety, travel, parenting, and more. A "strain coach" uses that score to make daily exertion recommendations to prevent burnout, which Quinn said helped evaluate her workout habits.
While the band itself is only $30, it requires a monthly membership that starts at $30 with a 12-month commitment. Annual membership goes up to $239 for access to the full Whoop suite.
LaceClips specs: Battery life: Ten days to three weeks, depending on use | Dimensions: 1.25 x 2 inches | Water/dust resistance: Water resistant | Connectivity: Bluetooth
Ever wonder how many steps Serena Williams tracks in a tennis match? What about how many steps running back Tyreek Hill takes? With LaceClips, a Bluetooth fitness tracker that strings through and secures to your shoelaces, you can find out -- and even compete against them.
Sure, you can use your smartphone to track steps or have a step competition with your mom, but I want a more competitive opponent -- no offense, mom. That's why in January, I kicked off my new year's movement goals by testing the LaceClips.
The LaceClips come in a pair, but only one is a tracking device equipped with a micro USB charging port. The other can be utilized for matching purposes or to help keep your laces in place. While it took eight hours for mine to fully charge, I usually got a good seven days of wear as I employed them to track my four-mile round-trip walking commute.
Unlike a smartphone or fitness watch, the clips don't passively track your steps. You'll have to download the LaceClips app, pair the clips, and actively select a workout for it to record your run, walk, or tennis match. Despite the extra step, the results were accurate and insightful, sure to count every step and even map out my route.
What is the best fitness tracker?
The Fitbit Charge 5 gets my vote for the best fitness tracker overall, thanks to its strong performance, excellent assortment of features, and reasonable price tag.
To see how it stacks up against the other picks on my list, here is an overview of the best fitness trackers.
Fitness tracker | ZDNET's take | Battery life | iOS and Android | Subscription |
The Fitbit Charge 5 | The best fitness tracker overall | Up to seven days, five days when using continuous GPS | ✓ | For premium, yes. |
The Oura Ring Gen 3 | The best subtle fitness tracker | Four to seven days | ✓ | Yes |
Apple Watch Series 8 | The best fitness tracker for Apple users | 18 hours | iOS only | No |
The Garmin Vívomove Trend | The best fitness tracker to wear from work to workout | Up to five days | ✓ | No |
The Whoop 4.0 | The best fitness tracker for sleep | Three to five days | ✓ | Yes |
LaceClips | The best screenless step tracker | Up to three weeks | ✓ | No |
Which is the right fitness tracker for you?
To help you find the best fitness tracker for your needs, these are my recommendations.
Choose this fitness tracker… | If you… |
Fitbit Charge 5 | Want the best fitness tracker overall, equipped with well-rounded features and the Fitbit ecosystem. The sleek design makes the best of the screen features without being distracting. |
The Oura Ring Gen 3 | Want the best subtle fitness tracker. The Oura Ring Gen 3 looks more like jewelry and provides a well-rounded approach to health and fitness. |
Apple Watch Series 8 | Want the best fitness tracker for the Apple ecosystem. The Apple Watch Series 8 can be customized to look more professional and offers accurate fitness and sleep tracking data. |
The Garmin Vívomove Trend | Want a fitness tracker that you can wear from work to the gym. This hybrid smartwatch has a small touchscreen as well as analog features, marrying time and fitness tracking. |
The Whoop 4.0 | Want a fitness tracker that is easy to sleep in. The Whoop "feels like nothing and tracks everything." It's subtle and easy to sleep in, and it takes a recovery-based approach to physical fitness. |
LaceClips | Want a screenless fitness tracker that tracks your steps. LaceClips keep your shoes laced and your motivation to get your steps in high, even allowing you to compete against professional athletes. |
How did I choose these fitness trackers?
As someone who likes to track my physical and mental fitness, including sleep tracking, I examined the aesthetic, fit, features like personal coaching and heart rate variability (HRV) measurement, battery life, and cost when narrowing down my focus.
I also considered my personal experience with fitness trackers I've tested and the hands-on experience of my fellow ZDNET team members. To get perspective outside of the ZDNET network, I talked to a former D1 athlete, Quinn Biggio, and Wake Forest Professor Dr. Jason Fanning.
Biggio's insight as an athlete helped me understand the benefits of choosing Whoop, especially when it comes to training and recovery. Dr. Fanning helped break down the aspects of health trackers I haven't personally tested, like the Oura Ring.
What does it mean if a fitness tracker measures heart rate variability?
Heart rate variability (HRV) is essentially the amount of time between your heartbeats.
Fitness trackers such as the Apple Watch Series 8, the Oura Ring Gen 3, and the Whoop measure HRV as a health metric using embedded sensors.
But what does that mean? According to Dr. Jason Fanning, it's measuring how responsive we are.
"If you think about your body at rest, you're able to stay at rest. But if somebody were to throw a rock at your head, you'd want to be able to mobilize and use energy to jump out of the way," he said. "Heart rate variability is a measure of sort of how responsive your system is. And it should be able to ramp up and back down again quickly."
Implementing HRV as a common metric prompts a more dynamic approach to fitness trackers, signaling overall wellness patterns to look out for over time as opposed to an immediate measurement.
As Dr. Fanning said, "If somebody's getting sick, their heart rate variability compresses, and they get less variability when they're at rest."
Recently, Dr. Fanning experienced the power of the HRV metric via his Oura Ring first-hand, "I just got over COVID last week and in the days prior to getting sick, my heart rate variability went through the floor."
What is a fitness tracker?
A fitness tracker is a device you wear on your body to track activity, whether you're walking around the house, going for a hike, or even sleeping. They can report on your health to help you improve your overall fitness and activity. The devices vary greatly, including anything from a step tracker to a more advanced smartwatch.
Do the best fitness trackers have apps?
Most of the best fitness trackers offer companion apps that allow you access to specific reporting, such as steps, rest, and sleep. These apps are typically available for both iOS and Android operating systems.
How much does a fitness tracker cost?
The cost of fitness trackers can vary significantly. The best fitness trackers range in cost from $30 to more than $300, depending on the model you choose. Many fitness trackers also allow you to customize the finish or style. Others may tack on subscription fees, which also impact the total price.
Are there alternative fitness trackers worth considering?
In our search for the best fitness trackers, we also found these excellent options.
STEP-TRACKING ALTERNATIVE
Garmin Running Dynamics pod
The Garmin Running Dynamics Pod has an unobtrusive, screen-less design and doesn't require you to actively record before starting a workout. You can't compete with athletes or secure on your shoe like with LaceClops, but it's a less expensive option.
RING ALTERNATIVE
Circular Ring
The Circular ring has a four-day battery and interchangeable outer shells. The ring focuses on sleep, activity, and health-tracking metrics.
For other ideas to improve your fitness, consider our picks for the best fitness rings, the best home gym equipment, and the best workout apps.