Should police need a warrant to collect evidence with drones?

A SWAT team standoff in California and a pending bill in Indiana highlight a fractured legal landscape with drones and public safety.
Written by Greg Nichols, Contributing Writer on

Should police need a warrant to collect evidence via drones? That question is currently before lawmakers in Indiana as they consider a bill to wipe out current prohibitions on drone use by police without first procuring a warrant.

Also: US military equipped with tiny spy drones 

Nationwide, there's no standard when it comes to police using drones, although the Supreme Court has weighed in generally on the subject in Florida v. Riley. In that case, the Court ruled there's no right to privacy when it comes to police observation in public airspace, reinforcing existing standards when it comes to the use of police helicopters.

In North Dakota, a 2015 law not only makes it legal for police to use aerial drones for surveillance, but also to equip drones with nondeadly weapons such as tasers.

Nonetheless, opponents draw a line in the sky when it comes to drones, which are much easier and cheaper to deploy for surveillance than helicopters, and which aren't subject to the same strict rules governing flight. A helicopter can't easily hover outside a window, for instance.

In 2013, Seattle famously reversed course and withdrew plans to equip local police with drones amid escalating protests. The California senate passed a bill that would have required police to secure a warrant for drone surveillance in 2014, but that bill was vetoed by then-Governor Jerry Brown, leaving the door open for police to use drones without warrants.

That's just what a SWAT team in Campbell, California, did earlier this month, deploying a new drone called the US-1 from Impossible Aerospace during a standoff with a suspect at a local Denny's. According to authorities, the drone, which is equipped with thermal and optical sensors and has a 90 minute battery life, provided perimeter surveillance and a view of the roof and exits. 

In that case, police ended up using tear gas to force the suspect out of hiding. The drone's sensors were able to confirm that an open kitchen vent was leaking some of the gas, prompting the SWAT team to alter their strategy to keep law enforcement safe. The standoff resulted in a peaceful arrest.

Impossible Aerospace, the company behind the drone, just procured $9.4 million in a Series A for its long-flying drones, which are crammed with battery cells that are distributed throughout the airframe. The company is specifically vying for lucrative government contracts in public safety, including police and firefighters.

Must read

"It's the unique capabilities of the US-1 that led our team to the arrest of the suspect, and kept our community safe," said Gary Berg, Police Captain in Campbell.

Operational use of drones is one thing, but privacy advocates worry that blanket mandates for drone use open the door to more insidious snooping by the state. That's motivating critics to voice opposition to the pending Indiana bill.

"It may sound like it's a reasonable use of technology to have a drone over a public street," Stan Wruble, a criminal defense attorney in South Bend, told a local ABC News affiliate. "However, over a public street you can obviously look into people's backyards, you can look into people's garage areas and if you have a reasonable expectation of privacy in those areas, this sort of turns into the big brother Orwellian nightmare scenario."

For now, the question is being settled on the local level, but it's clear that drone use by law enforcement is gaining popularity. Worldwide, the market for public safety drones is expected to grow to $1.15 billion by 2022

Humans vs. Robots, which species is winning?

Previous and related coverage:

Robotics in business: Everything humans need to know

An executive guide to the technology and market drivers behind the $135 billion roboticsmarket.

Living Machines: A quick history of robots (Part I)

Derided as abominations or celebrated as ingenious feats of human engineering, robots have been around longer than you think.

Wanted: Robot life coach (no, really)

The unique job is a hint of what's to come as robots increasingly join us in the human world

Gorgeous robots made of high tech paper are mesmerizing

Fifty students were given this shapeshifting paper and told to let their imaginations run wild. Here's what they came up with.

Related stories:

Editorial standards


How to add a credit card as a Bitwarden vault item and why you should
The Bitwarden item add button.

How to add a credit card as a Bitwarden vault item and why you should

Elon Musk tries to start a Twitter fight with Apple

Elon Musk tries to start a Twitter fight with Apple

LG Chem to spend $3.2 billion on cathode plant in the US for EV batteries
Tesla Model 3

LG Chem to spend $3.2 billion on cathode plant in the US for EV batteries