Why the future must be BYO AI: Model lock-in deters users and stifles innovation

Say goodbye to restrictive AI models and hello to a future where you choose the intelligence of your devices.
Written by Jason Perlow, Senior Contributing Writer
da-kuk/Getty Images

Artificial intelligence (AI) has quickly become a key selling point in consumer electronics, with new products like the Humane Ai Pin and Rabbit r1 making headlines. Despite their innovative use of AI, these devices have faced criticism for lacking other essential features and underperforming.

Also: Humane Ai Pin: What went wrong and how it can be fixed (before it's too late)

The expanding role of generative AI is hindered in various devices -- smart speakers, smartphones, wearables, and earphones -- due to the lack of choice for AI providers. Why? Most gadgets are bound to specific AI models or services because of manufacturer-exclusive partnerships or proprietary technologies. 

 For instance, devices like Humane Ai Pin and Rabbit r1 rely on OpenAI's GPT-4, which operates on Microsoft Azure. However, these devices (and apps) often experience performance issues because many users and services are connected to the shared hosted AI model simultaneously, and for the most part, they are not using dedicated instances. 

Also: The best free AI courses (and whether AI certificates are worth it)

Additionally, each device manufacturer may use separate cloud instances that have unique performance limitations for proxying API calls and prompts to the AI model from the device, which further affects device responsiveness.

Imagine a future where your devices, like a Sonos sound system, could seamlessly connect to any AI service provider -- from OpenAI's ChatGPT, Google's Gemini, to Apple's Siri, or a newcomer delivering unique interactive experiences. This "bring your own" (BYO) AI paradigm would break down closed ecosystems, allowing consumers to freely choose or switch between AI services as easily as they switch music streaming services -- thus enhancing control, fostering innovation, and intensifying competition in the tech industry.

The need for flexibility in AI model selection

The rapid advancement of AI technology underscores the critical need for flexibility in selecting AI models within consumer gadgets. As AI becomes more sophisticated, different models specialize in varied tasks -- from natural language processing to computational and creative functions. Consequently, the ability to choose from a diverse range of AI models is essential for users seeking customized digital experiences.

Because many consumer gadgets are restricted to specific models, users must settle for less-than-optimal AI services. It's reminiscent of the early mobile phone era when devices were tied to specific carriers -- a practice now largely abandoned due to consumer demand for choice and flexibility.

Also: The best AI chatbots: ChatGPT and alternatives

Furthermore, an AI model currently leading today's industry may be obsolete in just a few months, and users who are locked into one model risk having outdated technology.

The consumer benefits of BYO AI

Allowing consumers to choose their AI models enhances personalization and efficiency in device usage. Users can select AI models that align with their needs and lifestyles, such as prioritizing home automation over general knowledge and optimizing functionality for more efficient daily interactions.

Integrating multiple AI models into a single device can significantly extend the device's utility and lifespan. For example, a smart speaker might employ different AI models for command processing, home automation, and personalized entertainment, ensuring it remains functional and relevant for longer.

Also: The best AI image generators

Flexible AI model selection would empower consumers to tailor their technology interactions, fostering a user-centric approach that drives industry innovation, responsiveness, and competitiveness. This adaptability would improve user satisfaction and ensure devices keep pace with rapid technological advancements.

Moreover, the ability to switch between AI services will stimulate competition among providers, pushing them to improve their offerings. This competition will accelerate advancements in AI technology and generate more cost-effective solutions, granting consumers access to the latest technology at lower prices and motivating companies to innovate further.

Technological barriers to AI agnosticism

Creating an AI model-agnostic platform presents several technical challenges that must be addressed to enable seamless interoperability among devices and AI providers. One major hurdle is the compatibility of different AI models with various hardware platforms. Each AI service may have unique requirements for processing power, memory, and data formats, which can complicate integration across diverse devices. Furthermore, ensuring seamless communication among devices and AI models requires robust interface standards to handle the complex data exchanges necessary for AI functionalities.

Also: 2024 may be the year AI learns in the palm of your hand

Another significant technical challenge is developing a unified API supporting a wide range of AI services while maintaining high performance and security standards. This involves creating adaptable software that switches dynamically between AI models without compromising the user experience or device functionality. Achieving this would require a collaborative effort among AI developers, device manufacturers, and software engineers to establish a common set of protocols that support flexibility and scalability.

The regulatory challenges

Regulators are growing concerned about the flexibility of AI models in devices and their impact on consumer rights and market dominance. This issue is similar to the challenges faced by Apple and Amazon with their app stores and voice assistants. Regulators in various regions have expressed concerns about anti-competitive practices resulting from restricting consumers to specific ecosystems. For instance, the European Union has been actively legislating to ensure fair competition and consumer choice in digital markets, which may also apply to AI services. 

Also: The White House plans to regulate the government's use of AI

Companies that attempt to monopolize consumer access to AI may face legal and regulatory scrutiny by restricting compatibility with other AI services. Such practices could lead to investigations and penalties, such as those currently imposed on tech giants for antitrust violations in other areas of their operations. 

Regulatory frameworks may need to evolve to specifically address the interoperability of AI technologies and ensure that they foster an open and competitive market.

The role of open standards and protocols in the future of AI

To overcome the technological and regulatory challenges of generative AI, it's important that the industry adopt open standards and protocols rather than just open source the LLMs and AI models themselves. Open standards can promote interoperability by providing a common framework that all AI models and devices can follow, making integration simpler and reducing compatibility issues. This approach not only enhances consumer choice and flexibility but also promotes innovation, as developers are not limited by proprietary constraints.

Also: You can make big money from AI - but only if people trust your data

Open protocols have several benefits, including promoting competition in the market by preventing any single provider from monopolizing certain technologies. They also help address security concerns by maintaining AI transparent interactions and data handling across different platforms.

Embracing a flexible AI future in consumer devices

To truly advance AI in consumer technology, we must adopt a model of interoperability and flexibility similar to what is seen in other digital services. This means empowering users to select their preferred AI models and providers and adapting their devices to meet evolving needs and preferences.

Implementing a flexible AI model in consumer devices offers substantial benefits. It allows users to upgrade AI functionalities without needing new hardware, reducing the frequency of device replacements, minimizing electronic waste, and conserving resources. Additionally, using energy-efficient AI models can decrease power consumption, extend battery life, and lessen overall energy use, supporting both environmental sustainability and the advancement of green technologies.

Also: Meet your new IT superhero: Citizen developers flex their AI muscles

Moreover, a flexible AI approach promises to transform consumer technology by providing highly personalized experiences, making devices more adaptable, less wasteful, and better aligned with consumer desires.

While creating an AI model-agnostic platform presents significant technological and regulatory challenges, these are not insurmountable. Through cooperative efforts to develop open standards and adapt regulatory frameworks, we can facilitate a future where devices integrate AI in a more consumer-friendly and flexible manner.

Editorial standards