Tesla owner banned from driving after crash – and it's not over Autopilot

Driver gets a one-month ban for crashing while navigating the windshield-wiper settings on the touchscreen.
Written by Liam Tung, Contributing Writer

A German court has fined and banned a Tesla owner from driving for one month after a crash that happened while the driver was using the car's built-in touchscreen dashboard to adjust windshield-wiper settings.

Surprisingly, this case didn't involve Tesla's Autopilot system, which was activated in multiple crashes in the US and has drawn sharp criticism from the US National Transportation Safety Board

As reported by German tech site Golem, a regional court judge in Germany decided that the Tesla S's touchscreen user interface for controlling the intervals of the windshield wiper required too much attention from the driver. 

SEE: An IT pro's guide to robotic process automation (free PDF) (TechRepublic)

It therefore found him in breach of road-traffic regulations designed to stop people being distracted by their phones while driving.  

The decision, made in the Karlsruhe district court, involved a non-fatal crash in heavy rain on a federal highway. While changing the windshield-wiper settings, the driver crashed into a highway sign and several trees.

As the court noted, the Tesla driver could turn on the wiper from the steering wheel, just as on most cars. However, to change the interval of wipes, the driver needed to navigate through five settings in a submenu in the Tesla dashboard user interface after pressing a windshield icon on the touchscreen.  

Tesla's settings design wasn't considered responsible for the crash because it was the driver who should have understood that the system would take his attention off the road for too long. 

The court held that under German regulations Tesla's built-in touchscreen counts as an electronic device, which the driver can only legally use if it's an important control for the vehicle. Drivers can only legally use the touchscreen, the electronic device, if its use is brief and doesn't distract them from the road for too long. 

"The setting of the functions necessary for operating the motor vehicle via touchscreen (here: setting the wiping interval of the windshield wiper) is therefore only permitted if the view is only briefly adjusted to the screen based on road, traffic, visibility and weather conditions while at the same time looking away from the traffic situation," the decision reads.  

SEE: Microsoft's Project Freta: This new free service spots rootkits lurking in cloud VMs

As noted by Golem, the driver is held responsible even though the Tesla dashboard user interface design is entirely controlled by the electric vehicle maker.

ZDNet has contacted Tesla for comment and will update this article if it receives a response.

More on Elon Musk, Tesla, and self-driving cars

  • Tesla's Elon Musk: Our fully autonomous cars are now 'very close'  
  • Tesla hikes Full Self-Driving add-on by $1,000 – but Elon Musk says it's worth way more  
  • Tesla's big new feature: Autopilot now halts cars at red lights and stop signs  
  • Tesla fatal Model 3 crash: Autopilot's 'operational design' condemned  
  • Elon Musk: We've made 1 million Tesla electric cars  
  • Apple and Tesla under fire over software engineer's fatal Autopilot crash  
  • Tesla yanks Autopilot features from used car because 'they weren't paid for'  
  • US looks into over 100 complaints of Tesla cars suddenly accelerating and crashing  
  • New fatal Tesla crash: US road traffic regulator probes possible Autopilot link  
  • Elon Musk reveals Tesla's electric Cybertruck and smashes its windows  
  • Tesla's new Smart Summon: Here's why it has no place in public parking lots
  • Elon Musk: Older Tesla cars set for full self-driving chip upgrade in Q4  
  • Elon Musk on Tesla's Autopilot: In a year, 'a human intervening will decrease safety'
  • Fatal Tesla crash: Car was on Autopilot when it hit truck, say investigators
  • Elon Musk's new Tesla: Self-driving Model Y SUV out in 2020 from $47,000
  • Elon Musk: $35,000 Tesla Model 3 arrives but job cuts coming as sales shift online
  • Tesla starts to release its cars' open-source Linux software code
  • Tesla fatal crash: Parents of dead teen sue over alleged faulty battery
  • New NTSB Tesla fatal crash report: Model S battery reignited twice after Florida crash
  • NTSB's Tesla fatal crash report: Autopilot sped up, no braking in final seconds
  • Tesla Model S allegedly in Autopilot hits parked police car
  • Elon Musk: Tesla Autopilot gets full self-driving features in August update
  • Tesla's Autopilot: Cheat sheet TechRepublic
  • Tesla to close retail stores, only sell cars online CNET
  • Editorial standards